forum

Guess the song the user above prefers.

posted
Total Posts
76
show more
Dialect
Rook
2? 2 has more presence, 1 seems a little unremarkable in comparison, but whimsical and fun to listen to. Still I'd say you prefer 2.

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oQFD648nfmM
2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8QNb108WZt8
Topic Starter
Achromalia
#1 turned out to be pretty nice, and #2 is okay as well, but they have their different strengths and the selection seems just as good as the other.

I wonder if you were trying something new when you found #2?

- - -

Hello again! Don't mind me, just publicizing a friend of mine who's a singer .w.

1: https://soundcloud.com/alfianofong/nila ... et-version

2: https://soundcloud.com/slyleaf/slyleaf- ... ocal-cover
Rook
Ye, I like 2 more.

Damn, that's really cool! ov o
I'm guess you enjoy 2 more? They're both quite good, but the second one is just ❤

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i2ac5z_xnXc
2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pRHuvk-fzwo
keremaru
im gonna guess that you like 1 more, just based on the rate the music thread.

1): https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=yG30yDhpNps
2): https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zZ3bohoNNrU
Rook
Nah, it was 2

I think 1 fits my initial impression of you more... plus it sounds pretty nice.

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S-nwV0W4Pw0
2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=esAK9sKeArw
Topic Starter
Achromalia
I'd have no idea. Both songs are pretty good. I'll assume #1.

- - -

1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MB0PVBhWrwI

2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mmtv12NAj-4
Rook
2 for the sole reason I'm trying to sniff out some more doom metal/drone music to get into atm.

Ah both of these are great, methinks it'd be1 , just seems like the more self fulfilled tune.

1.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o9v5qFRA6Gw
2.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p3BDdiG0pIc
Topic Starter
Achromalia
Yet again, another close one. I've actually really liked #1, but there are some musical concepts in #2 I preferred. I would say that I would've liked #2 more as a composition, but the sound of its screams at some parts slightly take away from my experience with the song.

I had to value that by overall usage of interesting concepts, and #2 was the one to come out on top with that. #1 is constant in a sense and I like that, just not enough that hooks me in, even though i do love the sound of #1.

- - -

oof

Okay, so #1 here is pretty decent as far as the guitarwork goes. The vocals are alright and somewhat blend in, so it doesn't detract from the song or anything. It does seem a bit mediocre for what it does, though.

Then there's #2, with some pretty good instrumentation, it sounds nice, even if there isn't much inherently interesting, it's a familiar and nice arrangement. The thing about this one is the way the vocals are sung, and personally, it didn't work out that well. I do appreciate that it help set up a nice melancholic mood, but it's... well, something I'd be conflicted listening to. I do like how it ends, with a nice piano outro.

On second thought, I think I can get used to the vocals, it was just a little off-putting for me initially is all.

A bit hard to gauge. I feel like I should know enough about your taste by now but then here I am struggling to see what you'd prefer ( >~<)

#2? I dont know how you'd feel on the vocals for that. #1? Well, I'm not sure whether or not it's interesting.

hOlY sHiT this is difficult

I'll go with #2 as a quick guess, but the vocals are oof.

- - -

1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fgCKz7v7mso

2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r6hKxOocbJE
Rook
Karg's stuff has decent vocals ;v ;, achropls. It's not his greatest song though, but I generally love his sound even if his work is not that impressive compared to other similar artists. 1 is my favourite, one of the best songs in the genre, good melody and good aggression and... did you just call Carcass generic? I slap you!

Both of these are really fresh sounding. I'm leaning toward 2, 1 has those delicious noises thrown in and sounds very serene, I just feel it's a little ordinary though compared with some other similar stuff I've seen you post around before. 2 sounds a lot more expressive, the sounds are, to me, more intriguing and it kept me hooked for the whole duration.

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cn5xKJFl7NE
2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PjAb3GXHWdI
Topic Starter
Achromalia
Correct! #2 is one of the songs that made me really love the ambient IDM tracks for what they were. #1 was pretty close, but wasn't as satisfying as #2.

- - -

Hmm. Well first off, #1 has quite the intro. I liked that.

But I'll go with #2. Saor is a familiar name, and besides, I think it'd sound more fulfilling .w.

Rook wrote:

1 is my favourite, one of the best songs in the genre, good melody and good aggression and... did you just call Carcass generic? I slap you!
owch ;w;

i meant that the way this is done just feels too familiar, like it was done too often or that i recall something sounding like this before ( ~> A<)~

- - -

One should be familiar .w.

Easily accessed thanks to my youtube playlist for the good music from here.

Both songs i've liked for a while now.

1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Xewg-Uj1xk

2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VW6cxc2vKb4
Rook
Easily 2 ye, I don't actually like the first one besides the intro also and a few small moments. I've yet to find a Saor song I dislike, they're all 7+ to me.


Oho cunning tricks mon ami. SO, my weakling brain is telling me 2, it's a pleasant, interesting song and it'd fits in with the stuff I know you like, but that'd be too simple...(?) I'm not that surprised you like 1, you've been open to the genres I've been posting since the start afterall, you've mentioned progression a lot and comparative to other sludge-y stuff, this definitely has more prog elements than most, especially toward the end. Plus I had a massive grin on my face when I saw it was that song, so I kinda just want to say 1 anyway .v . . Besides, unless you're pulling meta tricks on me, I think its too obvious to say 2 even though I personally like 2 more now you showed it me. But maybe thats cus its a fresh listen for me.

i steal idea, tyty

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOoD0a0F2s8
2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kjd8aod5_hQ
Topic Starter
Achromalia
Correct again! Easy #1. I like #2, it is indeed the sorta stuff i like, but it is kinda empty and short, not too much about it to hook onto aside from the two main parts of the song, the drop, and everything that isn't the drop, both of which were pretty good. But #1, oof, #1 is easily one of my favorites you've sent ;w;

I dont intend to play tricks on you or anything (and I prefer not to be disingenuous, even if playing around is amusing), i just post two songs i enjoy and either make it easy or hard to decide between -w-

- - -

...

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

well then. time to judge. im kinda excited #1 was one of the first ones i sent, so uhh... i want to just immediately say #1.

#2 seema alright, but i just dont have much to say about it, even though there are good parts in it ( >n<)

#1...? Shit I'm second-guessing myself. #2 seems good as an experience. I wanna say #2, but I'll say #1 because I'm a dUmB and I liked #1 .w.

- - -

this is kind of a close one, but it might also be too easy.

1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Xp4PN1_MZk

2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DVdHw4fskj4
Rook
1 for sure, I'm obsessed with these vocals, they're just so appealing to me. Instrumentally I'd say its quite strong, but it's the vocals that really sell it to me.



Sooooooo
Personally I'm not into 1 that much, which kinda means I'm even more biased toward 2. That being said, as a whole experience, it definitely isn't unpleasant. In 12 minutes a lot does happen, like the whole section of 5:40 - 9:27 building up and changing very slightly, it never once had me bored...
But I love 2 so I have to think 2 ;v;

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9vP2mcXzRZ8
2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0LBQqPIpbI
Topic Starter
Achromalia
Triple kill! #1 is personally really enjoyable, mostly as an experience. I actually just fell asleep to it about 6 hours ago. But, I really do like #2, and it has more going for it in terms of content. I may prefer #1 for ambience, but in general, I'd prefer #2.

- - -

oof

#1 to me seems superior in ambience, mood, and content, quite honestly. As melancholic as it is, I kinda like it like that. Bittersweet stuff. Really easy to listen to, yet also full of what it needs to be what it is. In short, it's everything it needs to be.

#2 is pretty great to listen to in general, and I've always liked the song. I dont listen to it often, but when I do, I most certainly enjoy it. I just felt like #1 had taken the stage here.

- - -

Fighting memorable fires with nostalgic fire.

1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3pron-BYeGc

2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sCzJQRVbWtE
Rook
Both of them are relatively even, 1 is more complete as a song, I guess, but for the piano alone I prefer 2. But you are correct, it's 1.

O
2 is fantastic, holy.
I don't think I've heard it before or if I have then idk what happened to my ears. 1 is still one of my favourite songs you've posted though. Um, I'd say you prefer 2, but I'd also think it could be close. They're both quite different, 2 tries to be more unique where 1 is very ''standard'' but the execution of both of them is top stuff.

1.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kcGXKApAW9M
2.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fWshg65X2iU
HootOwlStar
just gonna hop into the game, even though this is going to be very difficult for me.
not sure but track two seems to bring out a stronger narrative comparatively, and the emphasis instrumentation wise in this track seem to be superior as well. so I'm gonna guess you enjoy 2 more.

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xiERPVIEvSc
2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Am5LEjrgeSc
jhen_old_1
Not entirely sure, so I'll take a guess. I think you prefer #2 more.

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wg2LEzMfhZM

2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tzIOlS2jX1s
Topic Starter
Achromalia
Rook
I'd guess 2, the mood is quite industrial and heavy sounding which is something I believe you'd like. 1 is quite empty in comparison, and I'm dumb cus I really can't see much to enjoy in it.

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzy1rEyHtbE
2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cHRHJoJTDCQ
Topic Starter
Achromalia
Well that was a close one. I like both of them for differing reasons, I think you might be right by saying I'd enjoy #2 a bit more, as an experience.

Personally I liked the sort of atmosphere and mood #1 had, and the intro was pretty interesting to me when i first heard it. Though #1 didn't have much that was catchy like #2 did, the little experimental directions it goes it, along with the spooky mood and soft yet crunchy atmosphere and texture being presented with #1 would be why I'd like it.

#2 is indeed fairly industrial and is more grounded and earthy, yet metallic in texture. It has a pretty catchy theme to it. The breathy vocal in the back is pretty interesting in how it adds to the experience. It works pretty well in my opinion. The lyrics, though hard to discern at times, are pretty eerie.

I think there's plenty to like about both, but you'd be correct, that the first song is a little empty in comparison to the second.

- - -

Hmm. #1 has a style I'd typically associate with you when I listen to the music you submit, and it's familiar. But, I'm getting the feeling perhaps #2 would work out better for you? I think you might like both of them quite a bit, so it's a bit hard to choose.

- - -

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=54YyWYP4r8s

2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H3-Y6EyxEoo
Rook
Yep, it's 2. I like 1 but I think it's quite safe, 2 just suits my taste more at this moment.

2 again? 2 sounds a little more innovative where I think 1 has more charm, so idk. The chimes in 1 I personally really like, but 2 shifts and changes and keeps things fresh throughout the listen which I'd say is more your thang.

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V-lkAXgRML8
2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3B2dQyLk9Ag
TeeArctic1
I'm going to guess 1 based entirely on my gut feeling. It completely killed my ears though, did not expect that volume.

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pzNZllh3JNI
2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FY3QaOA5FPU
Rook
2. Not generally into indie, but I love how soothing it sounds.

1 is more intricate and has a great mood, great voice too. 2 has some sass and is a large degree more jazzy and upbeat. Probably wrong, but I'll guess 2.

1.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tHCxKy2xWHs
2.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X34PsRY1NT4
TeeArctic1
2. Although I love No. 4, Glu by Fieh has a special place in my heart.

I'll guess you'd be more into 1. as it's more transformative and changes between atmospheric and calm to upbeat and energetic. It's beautiful either way

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_wHXxjUsdg
2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qTUnDV3MgVQ
Topic Starter
Achromalia
Considering your personality I'd legitimately think you'd prefer 2.

Hmm.

1: https://soundcloud.com/hook_music/myrko ... t-hook-vip

2: https://soundcloud.com/hook_music/hook- ... e-download
keremaru
samX500
This game seems fun so Imma revive it.

I don't know your music preference so I am gonna guess the second song because it is faster and more intense and I feel like most people prefer these sort of song.

1) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHJUzezRV1k
2) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CkKCY_pCPi8
AHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Probably the second one since your ava is from the same show and I kinda guess that that show plays a huge role of getting you turn into a euphonium maniac

Gonna choose 2 completely different genres to make it hard
1)

2)
samX500

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHH wrote:

Probably the second one since your ava is from the same show and I kinda guess that that show plays a huge role of getting you turn into a euphonium maniac
Good reasoning but the first song is also from the same show. I love both of these song in different ways. The first song is an amazing duo that express intense emotions where as the second song is a very quiet and calm solo. I'd say I prefer the first one.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

For you I feel like it would be the second song. I remember you posting a few similar song to it in rate the above user's music.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2 extremely similar yet different song

1)


2)
AHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

samX500 wrote:

For you I feel like it would be the second song. I remember you posting a few similar song to it in rate the above user's music.


Yep. Even though the first song is really good and kinda unique, almost nothing can beat the second song. The drop was so unique that I haven't seen anything like that from other song.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Nothing beat the second one, so imma choose 2. It is just too good for 1 imo. Also I figure that you would prefer sth more chill

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Again, 2 completely different genre



Carmlillball
I'm guessing you'd be more into T-Human/Psytrance?




And I guess I've killed the thread 👏👏👏
samX500
Don't worry, AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH and I won't let this thread die.

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHH wrote:

Nothing beat the second one, so imma choose 2. It is just too good for 1 imo. Also I figure that you would prefer sth more chill


Yup you are right. Dango daikazoku and chiisana tenohira are actually my two favorite song of all time. They are very similar in that they both share the melody of Clannad ost Nagisa, however, the emotion they convey are different.

To me, Chiisana tenohira convey a beautiful optimism in our future generation.

Dango daikazoku though, is simply the most recomforting song there is. This songs tells you that despite how sad you may be, that you still have to move on strong. It's always the song I come to when I am feeling sad, and it is the very first song I want to learn to play on the euphonium.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I'll take my bet on song number 1, from what I remember it's the kind of song you always post on rate the above user's song.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

My choice will be two different vocaloid cover. It shouldn't be too hard to guess which one I prefer.

1-


2-
Carmlillball
I'll take my bet on song number 1, from what I remember it's the kind of song you always post on rate the above user's song.

Yep! :3

-----------------------------------------------
I'll guess 1? 2 sounds awful imo!
-----------------------------------------------
Even I barely know, here!



Bloom
1st one would be closer to my preference, but I wouldn't pick it if there were better choices.

--------------

I suppose #1 would be a safe pick

https://youtu.be/Jyj1u5o65tg

https://youtu.be/E_kbWkHV9TE

Quick Q: How do I embed YT vids?
keremaru
shit this is hard.

uh, i'll go with 2 because it's a cool song. though you might've set me into a stalemate with your touhou ava.

by the way it's [youtube]v= code[/youtube]




AHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

Carmlillball wrote:

I'm guessing you'd be more into T-Human/Psytrance?

Nope. The 2nd song is really good, but the 1st one is definitely sth else. It’s so charming in a way.

————————————

Gonna guess the 2nd one, since I know more people that would prefer galaxy collapse to ghost and idrk your music taste

————————————

Again, 2 completely different genre



samX500
Edit: forgot to to give my answer to Carmalilbal

Wrong it was 2. Teto is best Utauloid. I actually don't like Miku that much, her voice isn't really great in my opinion. I like a good number of her song but it's mostly just because she has far more song made for her than any other vocaloid/utauloid.

----------------------------------------------------------------

My guess is on song number 2 since I know you love the piano.

-----------------------------------------------------------------

Here are two great oboe song.

1-


2-
Zelzatter Zero
I guess it's one

1.


2.
Ashton
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply