1. Easy (1.31 stars, 165 notes)
2. Hard (4.66 stars, 369 notes)
3. Normal (3.24 stars, 261 notes)

1. Your Background size (Ellie_Goulding_bg) is 1022x768 which is unrankable. It must be 1024x768 in this case. Use this one instead:
   
   SPOILER

   
2. Consider adding some tags if possible. Consider adding "Lights" in tags since that is the name of the album!
3. (optional) I believe that the BPM is 105.00 instead of 210.00 since it's a relatively slow and relaxing song!
4. Your hitsound volumes are too loud! Try reducing all of your hitsound volumes by 30-40%

1. 00:30:271 (2,3) - I think you should convert these 2 hit circles into a slider to be consistent with 00:35:414 (2).
2. 00:37:986 (1,2) - To be consistent with 00:43:129 (1), I think you should add a drum-clap at the end of slider 1. Also, consider removing circle 2 here, since there is no audible instrument playing here. If fixed, I recommend removing the note at 00:44:271 (2).
3. 00:48:271 (1) - Improve this slider's shape:
   
   Image and Code

   
   

   372,336,48271,6,0,B|292:300|256:336|220:372|140:336,1,240,2|4,1:2|0:0,2:0:0:0:

4. 00:59:700 (2) - Delete this note. There's nothing audible here.
5. 01:00:271 (3,4) - (Nazi) These hit circles are not symmetrical.
6. 01:04:843 (2) - Again, delete this note since there is nothing to emphasize.
7. 02:19:700 (5,6) - (Nazi) Not exactly parallel. Move slider 6 a grid down.

1. 00:27:700 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Why not use the rhythm as 00:37:986 (1,2,3,4,5,6)? It's sounds better with the music imo.
2. 03:03:700 (2,5) - These slider shapes can be improved more I guess. :/

1. I recommend Overall Difficulty 7 for a better difficulty spread. For example: Easy difficulty has OD3, Normal has OD5, and Hard has OD7.

BeatofIke wrote:

Hello Xgor! Mod 4 Mod Request from #modreqs! Most are just suggestions!

[General]

1. Your Background size (Ellie_Goulding_bg) is 1022x768 which is unrankable. It must be 1024x768 in this case. Use this one instead:
   
   SPOILER

   
2. Consider adding some tags if possible. Consider adding "Lights" in tags since that is the name of the album!
3. (optional) I believe that the BPM is 105.00 instead of 210.00 since it's a relatively slow and relaxing song!
4. Your hitsound volumes are too loud! Try reducing all of your hitsound volumes by 30-40%

[Easy]

1. 00:30:271 (2,3) - I think you should convert these 2 hit circles into a slider to be consistent with 00:35:414 (2).
2. 00:37:986 (1,2) - To be consistent with 00:43:129 (1), I think you should add a drum-clap at the end of slider 1. Also, consider removing circle 2 here, since there is no audible instrument playing here. If fixed, I recommend removing the note at 00:44:271 (2).
3. 00:48:271 (1) - Improve this slider's shape:Done
   
   Image and Code

   
   

   372,336,48271,6,0,B|292:300|256:336|220:372|140:336,1,240,2|4,1:2|0:0,2:0:0:0:

4. 00:59:700 (2) - Delete this note. There's nothing audible here.Lyrics <.<
5. 01:00:271 (3,4) - (Nazi) These hit circles are not symmetrical.Oh yeah, fixed
6. 01:04:843 (2) - Again, delete this note since there is nothing to emphasize. Lyrics
7. 02:19:700 (5,6) - (Nazi) Not exactly parallel. Move slider 6 a grid down.Done

[Normal]

1. 00:27:700 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Why not use the rhythm as 00:37:986 (1,2,3,4,5,6)? It's sounds better with the music imo.The thing is that they sound a little bit different and they are made
2. 03:03:700 (2,5) - These slider shapes can be improved more I guess. :/Done

Some of your combos are too long. Consider converting some of the hitcircles to sliders to help reduce the combo length to 8 and under. There are also a few inconsistent rhythms. Some of the notes you placed are not even audible with the music.Rythms are mostly based on lyrics and the differences is due to that. Let's face it, mapping to only instuments can end up really repitive and boring. About the combos, I did some of them shorter

[Hard]

1. I recommend Overall Difficulty 7 for a better difficulty spread. For example: Easy difficulty has OD3, Normal has OD5, and Hard has OD7.Done

Good Luck!

CDFA wrote:

WHOOIII DAWWNNT YEEEW BEEE DA AWTAAEEESSTT

Overall:
00:27:700 - Good hitsounding for this beginning part, but I feel that the song doesn't really call for it, as it's still theoretically in the introduction, and makes the hits later much less effectiveEh, I lowred the hitsounds, should make a bit better.
I find this 3/4 BPM thing weird. It works just fine in 4/4 at 70 BPM.It's a bit weird, but at the same 70 BPM is kinda awkard too and would make for the worst timing signature ever.

Hard:
00:40:271 (2) - Maybe stack this with (1). It feels a bit weird atm
01:07:700 (5) - Add NCDunno, that feels just wrong
01:23:414 (7) - Add clapDone
01:25:986 (3) - Add clap on end of sliderDone
01:38:843 (4) - Add clap on beginning of sliderDunno, feels just so wrong for me.
01:40:271 (6) - NCDone
02:35:986 (6) - ^
02:44:557 (5) - These usually look a lot better going downward rather than upward.Eh, I like them.
03:06:271 (8) - Add clapDone
03:35:986 (1) - I'm going to assume that this was a mistake or something.<.< You didn't see that. I can't have done such and embarrassing mistake. >.>

Normal:
01:16:557 - Add note with clapI dunno. It just feels odd for me.
Sweet.

Easy:
01:31:129 (4) - This starts awkwardly for easy players but it's hard to actually make this right without adding notes on the white ticks before, which in turn can mess up the pattern you have. Think about it making it more comfortable for normal players, but I understand that with the pattern, it's hard.Well, I moved it a tick earlier, homefully it becomes a little bit easier
02:09:700 (1) - Add clap on end of sliderDone
02:13:128 (5) - Clap on repeatDone
02:16:557 (2) - Add clap on end of sldierDone
02:26:843 (4,5) - Same as 1:31Same as the other one

Sweet.

1. i dont really like the combo colours that you used i don't think they fit with bg, why don't you try to use this colours,they are a little bit softer as yours:
   
   SPOILER

   

   Combo1 : 107,181,64
   Combo2 : 223,227,60
   Combo3 : 200,198,215

1. 01:25:700 (7,9) - try to don't stack

1. 02:26:843 - try to finish this slider at 02:27:414 atm sounds strange

1. 01:51:414 - new combo here
2. 01:56:271 - new combo here

Mashley wrote:

My last mod was 15 months ago so here's a shit mod.
Generally speaking I see no reason not to map the last soft chorus. You're missing an opportunity there for a nice ending to it.I don't agree mapping the last soft chorus would be somewhat of
Breaks seem very short, especially for a normal or easy player they might need a little more time to recover themselves. 02:37:414 could be very easily extended.I think they are good enough, and as the part after it is a bit easier it kinda works as a break

Easy
I feel like the rhythms in the vocal line of the bridge may be confusing for a beginner, maybe try mapping to something different. Otherwise really nice.I did repeat sliders so the it became a little bit easier, still kinda hard to map that part without sounding awkard

Normal
Nothing's striking me here. A good solid map.

Hard
Early section plays a little weird, perhaps since there's no drums in the music. Dunno how you'd fix that though.
02:05:414 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - I see what you were going for with this but the pattern doesn't really achieve that, just plays a little oddly and breaks the map's flow. Maybe try something more similar to the previous pattern for this.I dunno, I feel that the flow works great for this pattern, even better than the one before the
02:25:985 (7,8,9) - Rearrange these into a more even triangle, perhaps?This wasn't really intended as a triangle, buut I improved it,
02:59:414 - Personally I would have some notes here to build better into the chorus.Yeah, done
03:13:986 (1) - Looks kind of ugly to me how it's opposite but not symmetrical to the previous slider, try some different patterns and see if you find something better.Changed a bit but if I made it symmetrical I had to make it kinda ugly to work so I didn't do that.

Good work on this map, nice and bullshit-free.

BounceBabe wrote:

Don't you accept my mod or do you ignore me? o.o