Xelasto wrote:

Hello!

[Easy]00:31:231 (4) - Don't overlap. It's simply too confusing for beginners. Put it to the left maybe.
00:36:915 (1) - Are you sure about putting these types of sliders in easy? This could EASILY confuse a beginner if he has never seen one. I'm sure about this one, it's the only way to catch the beat of the song without making it harder
00:46:389 (4) - This is the same situation with the first problem, except worse. This may be obvious to you, but not to a new player.
00:47:968 (2) - ^
00:58:073 (3) - ^
01:08:178 (3) - ^
01:17:968 (1,2,3,1) - The spacing here is off. 2 + 3 are closer to 1 even though on the timeline 2 and 3 are closer to 4 (ryhthmically)
01:20:494 (1,2,3,1) - Same thing here.
01:23:021 (1,2,3,4,1,2,1,2,1,2) - Space these out just a bit, so it's clearer. When they're scrunched up like this new players tend to panic (Trust me, I've seen it )
01:37:547 (4) - Don't hide this under the slider
01:46:073 (3,4,1) - This looks cool, but too many overlaps.
02:17:652 (2) - Don't hide this under the slider, especially since there is another slider incoming. Here's a suggestion

SPOILER

02:29:336 (1) - Why such a harsh SV change? this is supposed to follow the scream, mapping the actual guitar here would make it too hard
02:34:389 (1) - ^ ^
02:39:442 (1) - ^ ^
02:32:810 (2) - Don't overlap. Move in-between sliders for more clarity
02:46:073 (2) - ^
02:53:021 (1,2) - Don't overlap
02:58:389 (5) - ^
03:05:652 (1) - Don't overlap especially since it blends in. Newcomers tend to focus on what is coming next.
03:08:494 (5) - I REALLY suggest you put this closer and don't overlap. Not only is it blending in, but it is a huge jump for beginners and it interrupts the flow of the song. I also suggest you put the rest of the notes after this closer, so it's not so big a gap.
03:10:389 (2,3,4) - Space out.
03:16:389 (2,3) - You sure about overlapping?
03:20:494 (2,3,4) - Space out.
03:27:126 (3,4,5) - Insanely confusing overlapping.
03:33:126 (4) - Don't hide this under the slider.
03:49:863 (2) - Space out a bit, don't hide it under the last slider.
HP Drain 2.5 so making mistakes doesn't have too big a consequence. fixed
I also highly suggest that you go through your song with Distance Snap on since the spacing isn't consistent and perfect. will do

I'm a complete beginner at mapping anything lower than insane lol so I'll have all the overlaps and spacings redone with distance snap when I have time

Overall this is a good map except the readability isn't exactly high enough for new players, and the spacing sometimes suggest that something is faster than it really is.

[Ra Ra Ra Rah]00:52:073 (1,2,3) - Make them more neat. fixed the distance a little bit, the position is fine though
01:29:810 (6) - NC for some health regen after hard part. started NC on the triple right after instead
01:39:915 (1,2,3) - Make them neat. distance fixed
01:43:863 (1,2,3,4) - Make the next 4 notes overlap these this is made on porpuse
02:14:178 (1) - Make this blanket 3 fixed
02:24:284 (1) - Make this neater fixed
02:29:652 (6) - NC to match the music this would make too many NC's, I htough about it but I'll keep it
02:29:968 (10) - ^
02:30:284 (14) - ^
02:32:178 (5) - ^
02:32:494 (9) - ^
02:33:757 (5) - ^
AR 9 the insane will be ar9, this has to be 9.3 :b

Sorry this mod for insane wasn't much. I have never modded insane. it was really helpful don't be so hard on yourself :3

I won't be modding normal or hard since they aren't finished.

Since I gave a sup-bar mod, you only have to mod one difficulty on mine. Please mod my hard mode. I'm still learning to mod sorry about that. the mod was great, don't worry about it, I'll give you a full mod to the best of my abilities

Chocox wrote:

Hello from my Q ^^

[Click me for Mod!]Formatting sux >.<
[General]
You might want to enable custom colours fixed

[Easy]
I think some parts here are too hard to read for a beginner , I suggest using Distance Snap to map for Easy and Normal (Ctrl-Shift-A). http://puu.sh/dAFz1/29079157ec.png
If you are able to I suggest reworking on this difficulty , and mapping to distance snap , make it as easy as possible like in the previous mod, I'll rework that, will take some time though
00:41:968 (1,2) - This is hard to read for people who just started the game you might want to change the position of 2
00:45:757 (3,4) - This is also hard to read
00:47:021 (1,2) - This is hard to read
00:57:126 (2,3) - Hard to read , maybe not stack them
I don't think there's any other problem besides all these spacing issues , nice blankets in this map everything will be fixed with the rework, hopefully

[Normal]
Same as Easy , maybe map to Distance Snap
01:03:442 (1) - I think this is stacked to tail of 01:02:178 (3) , maybe place it properly , maybe not if you're following to distance snap
01:17:337 (4,2) - I think this is ugly overlap , because 2 appears before 4 end
01:46:073 (3,1) - This one too , imo , because 1 appears before 3 ends
02:15:126 (3) - This slider is too late , try a 1/1 slider http://puu.sh/dAGgq/087e01ed24.png this is following vocals, I might change it because it is hard to read for a normal

The patterns are fine to me , just some parts need to be worked on same as easy, will be reworked to distance snapped

AxE Galaxy wrote:

Normal:
-02:08:178 (1,2) - Slightly increase slider speed to make these two sliders longer because it feels kinda slower than I expected when playing. I never felt that, but I will change if more people notice the same thing.
-suggestion 03:11:968 , 03:22:037 Gives each leg a grey elbow in the center and move the elbows slightly outwards. I didn't quite get what you mean, but imo they're are fine like this

Hard:
-opinion 01:23:652 I don't like this double circles placed upon each other. I'll prefer it to be a stream like 01:28:862 I did think of that too, but it would make that part harder than it needs to be, I'll still try to think of something better though.

Ra Ra Rah:
-00:30:599 (1,2,3,4) this looks ugly to me. Place the 3 cricles higher and closer to the y-axis. Let the slider leave downwards in a curve... more or les like 00:29:020 removed stack, fixed
-01:01:231 turn this slider around and move 01:00:737 to the slider's new start. move 01:00:915 downwards to adjust the cursor's flow. Also trun 01:01:862 around and move it downwards. I find that part really fun and not so flow breaking, leaving for now
-01:17:652 , 01:22:705 move it closer to the next slider fixed
-suggestion 02:58:073 turn this slider around that combo is supposed to be cross jumping, that would have better flow from last note, but worse for the next note
-03:06:757 (3,4) I don't know where to find the screenshots when I upload them so I'll try to explain... rotate 3 by 90 deg. anti-clockwise and 4 by 90 deg. clockwise. Let 4 end in 3's curve and adjust the 2 sliders's position. that would make the jump too small for what i'm trying to achieve, would be nice too though

Sky Trias wrote:

Hi! Summon from #modreqs

Since hard still W.I.P i'm not gonna mod that ..
when ready call me on game or msg for further mod from me

• [ Ra Ra Ra Rah]

1. Please don't spamming New Combo .. it's not unrankable will rework combos on this diff, definately I spammed them a little ahah
   
2. 00:30:600 (1,2,3) - can you make the mirror of 00:31:231 (1,2,3) - ? done!
3. 00:39:126 (4) - space please ? or you just put in right side of 00:38:810 (1,2,3) - to make flow better done!
4. 00:48:600 (2) - ctrl+g - flow broken this is on purpose though, I might change if more people feel bothered by this part
5. 00:49:231 (4) - ^ ^
6. 00:58:705 (2) - ^ ^
7. 01:04:705 (6) - ctrl+g and 01:05:021 (7,8) - make flow better ^
8. 01:14:178 (5) - ctrl+g I did try this one for a bit but I find the current slider more fun
9. 01:17:021 (6) - ^
10. 02:23:021 (5) - ^ I think this would break flow
11. 02:31:547 (4) - ^ would be harder to get into 2nd part of the stream
12. 02:58:073 (4) - ^ that combo is supposed to be cross jumping, that would have better flow from last note, but worse for the next note

Also add tag : Tarrasky , Flyxz (for GD) done!

I hope this helping helps a lot ^^
GL! Milhofo

18:15 ByBy_ChAn: you're ready ?
18:17 Milhofo: ready :D
18:18 ByBy_ChAn: okay
18:19 ByBy_ChAn: I saw in the majority of the maps which they have grid level 4
18:19 ByBy_ChAn: well change the grid level
18:19 ByBy_ChAn: to all difs
18:19 ByBy_ChAn: *diffs
18:20 Milhofo: make them all the same?
18:20 Milhofo: sure
18:20 ByBy_ChAn: yes
18:27 ByBy_ChAn: you are there 
18:27 ByBy_ChAn: ?
18:28 Milhofo: yeah
18:28 ByBy_ChAn: okay
18:28 ByBy_ChAn: the offset is wrong
18:28 Milhofo: I'm fixing things as you say them ^^
18:28 ByBy_ChAn: okay
18:29 Milhofo: mhm I tried several offsets this one seemed the best
18:29 ByBy_ChAn: I don't think so 
18:32 ByBy_ChAn: the correct offset is 27442  
18:33 ByBy_ChAn: set on 00:27:442 (1)-   to all diffs
18:35 Milhofo: that's after my first timing point in the insane, I don't think it's possible
18:35 ByBy_ChAn: is possible
18:37 Milhofo: http://puu.sh/dLoaE/03cca1894c.jpg
18:37 Milhofo: it gives me that error, because offset is after 1st green timing section
18:38 Milhofo: I'm a new mapper, maybe I'm doing something wrong ..
18:38 ByBy_ChAn: yeap
18:38 ByBy_ChAn: set a green line all on 00:27:442 (1)- where is the offset 
18:38 ByBy_ChAn: apply to all diffs
18:40 ByBy_ChAn: and delete the green lines from 00:25:389 ()- and 00:25:705 ()-
18:40 ByBy_ChAn: on all diffs
18:40 Milhofo: okay
18:44 ByBy_ChAn: you applied ?
18:45 Milhofo: ok finished applying now
18:45 Milhofo: all fixed
18:45 ByBy_ChAn: sweeeet :3
18:45 ByBy_ChAn: in easy , check the ai mod
18:45 ByBy_ChAn: you have 18 DS errors
18:47 Milhofo: mine seems fine
18:47 Milhofo: http://puu.sh/dLoFL/cd197d8463.jpg
18:47 Milhofo: that's the easy diff
18:47 ByBy_ChAn: yes
18:47 Milhofo: what do you mean by DS? design?
18:47 ByBy_ChAn: no
18:48 ByBy_ChAn: DS -> Distance Snap
18:49 Milhofo: I didn't even know that existed xD I'll take a look
18:49 ByBy_ChAn: click in ai mod ''check distance snap''
18:50 Milhofo: already checking it :)
18:50 ByBy_ChAn: okay
18:50 ByBy_ChAn: good
18:56 ByBy_ChAn: I think to fix that errors , use hmmm 1.3 because the objects are so close
18:58 Milhofo: 1.3? SV?
18:58 ByBy_ChAn: no DS
18:59 ByBy_ChAn: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2395327 
18:59 Milhofo: got it
18:59 Milhofo: I'm learning new things xD
18:59 ByBy_ChAn: where is writed ''distance spacing
18:59 ByBy_ChAn: wow
19:00 Milhofo: yeah this was my first serious map ._.
19:00 ByBy_ChAn: hmm..
19:00 ByBy_ChAn: yea
19:00 ByBy_ChAn: now 2 months I was a newbie too
19:01 ByBy_ChAn: but I cacthed experience
19:01 ByBy_ChAn: *catched
19:07 Milhofo: I'm trying to fix some DS errors and it doens't do anything..
19:07 Milhofo: it says the error is still there..
19:07 ByBy_ChAn: lemme try
19:13 ByBy_ChAn: at me works
19:13 ByBy_ChAn: try to move all objects on all diffs
19:13 ByBy_ChAn: *diff
19:14 Milhofo: lol rip me
19:14 ByBy_ChAn: np
19:14 Milhofo: and the diff will not be easy anymore
19:14 Milhofo: it's just on 1.5 stars..
19:14 ByBy_ChAn: what ? it's not a problem
19:15 Milhofo: do DS errors make it unrankable?
19:15 ByBy_ChAn: yes
19:16 Milhofo: lol it's perfectly playable ; ;
19:16 Milhofo: oh well 4 more hours to re do another diff..
19:17 ByBy_ChAn: hmm
19:17 ByBy_ChAn: yeap
19:17 ByBy_ChAn: and I to mod a marathon map ;w;
19:18 Milhofo: gl xd
19:19 ByBy_ChAn: thanks
19:19 ByBy_ChAn: also I saw some overlaps
19:19 ByBy_ChAn: it is not good
19:19 ByBy_ChAn: you should avoid the overlaps
19:20 ByBy_ChAn: example I saw in normal diff and easy
19:23 Milhofo: I'll try to fix what I find..
19:23 ByBy_ChAn: okay
19:23 Milhofo: since I'll have to redo it..
19:23 ByBy_ChAn: yyea
19:24 ByBy_ChAn: also I see some blankets which are not so good
19:24 ByBy_ChAn: my luck I have a picture with a good blanket
19:25 Milhofo: ok
19:29 ByBy_ChAn: [url=https://up.ppy.sh/files/screenshot125-8.jpg]Good blanket[/url]
19:29 ByBy_ChAn: Maybe you understood
19:30 ByBy_ChAn: I will post now the irc
19:30 Milhofo: I did dw ^^ the image is getting an error (site down) but I got it
19:30 Milhofo: sure, just put it on the thread
19:30 ByBy_ChAn: okay
19:30 ByBy_ChAn: so this is the end of the irc :3