1. Cataclysm (5.74 stars, 784 notes)
2. Easy (1.51 stars, 90 notes)
3. Hard (3.35 stars, 298 notes)
4. Insane (4.51 stars, 444 notes)
5. Normal (2.07 stars, 167 notes)

Cheesecake wrote:

Hi, from modding queue

[Insane]

00:03:987 (2) - Ctrl+G I do fancy all my sliders pointing upwards
00:07:587 (4,5) - Make this blanket by doing this I'll make it more ambiguous whether it's supposed to be a blanket or not
00:40:887 (1,1) - Ew this overlap Unnoticeable ;d
00:57:687 (1,2,1,1,2,1) - Well this is new, I don't think buzz sliders are too hard for 4.5* I like long sliders


[Cataclysm]

00:10:587 (5,6) - This is really misleading imo, I'd reccomend a good ol' Ctrl+G I like the little anti-jump there
00:13:887 (3) - Make this a bit closer to 00:13:287 (1) - so that 00:13:287 (1,2,3) - this whole part is equidistant I'll make it more ambiguous whether they're supposed to be equidistant or not
00:36:237 (2) - Ctrl+G? I do fancy all my sliders pointing downwards
00:51:687 (1) - I'm not sure if these should really be 1/8, all the gaps make it sound really weird as well (this applies for this whole section up to 01:15:387 (8) - ) I think it plays fine
01:28:587 (8,9,1) - Flow from (9) to (1) doesn't look good, try and see if you can make this part flow clockwise rather than anti-clockwise or however you want to do it so that it flows into 01:28:887 (1) - properly Oks
01:37:887 (9) - NC Oks

Good luck

Spiral527 wrote:

from my queue

Hard

00:07:212 (3,1) - don't stack like this, move these down to make them more visible spacing them more kinda goes against my intentions for this pattern
00:09:087 (2) - stack the head of this on the tail of 00:07:887 (3) Why?
01:19:287 (1) - move this up more, it blocks too much of the next slider Intentional
01:42:087 (1,2) - when I was a hard player I didn't like stacking like this. Can't say I'm a fan now I don't see a problem with it, and if I remain consistent it should be fine
01:43:287 (1,2) - ^
01:46:887 (1,2) - ^
01:48:087 (1,2) - ^
01:52:887 (1,2) - ^
01:54:087 (1,2) - ^

Normal

00:03:687 (2) - not sure if this is intentional, but the sliderslide here is drum (which seems to be intentionally avoided elsewhere) Yes they're intentional
01:50:487 (1) - ^
02:00:087 (1) - ^

01:21:687 (1) - beautiful slider (not part of my mod, just wanted to say that)

Couldn't find anything in Insane or Cataclysm which is why I didn't mod them

1. 00:25:137 (1) - Wouldnt it make more sense to end the slider on the white tick? (theres an actual sound there)
2. 00:51:687 (1,2,3,1,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5) - For this section i think you should lower the volume to around 45% as oppose to 60%
3. 02:04:737 - Add a note here? (its fine either way)
4. 02:10:587 (4) - I think if you made this slider 1/8 instead of 1/4 itd have a nice build up to the finish. (also compliments the build up cymbal)

NucleaRaven wrote:

Hi from my queue o/

[Cataclysm]

1. 00:25:137 (1) - Wouldnt it make more sense to end the slider on the white tick? (theres an actual sound there) Mapping the wubwub
2. 00:51:687 (1,2,3,1,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5) - For this section i think you should lower the volume to around 45% as oppose to 60% Hmm makes sense. I've changed hitsound volumes around the map as well now that you've mentioned it
3. 02:04:737 - Add a note here? (its fine either way) Hmmm I'd like to slow down this part as much as possible, and adding a note makes it too fast
4. 02:10:587 (4) - I think if you made this slider 1/8 instead of 1/4 itd have a nice build up to the finish. (also compliments the build up cymbal) Nah I think the 1/4 is enough and I get a nice pattern out of it

Amazing map gl with rank Tyty

Potato-chii wrote:

00:18:687 (4) – If you want a blanket here, maybe fix it. And I’d recommend you to take the slider end away from 00:18:387 (3) because newbies often mistake it as the slider head.

Potato-chii wrote:

02:11:037 (1) – Why end spinner there? Why not here 02:14:487 ?

Potato-chii wrote:

01:08:487 (1) – Maybe not this shape again?

Scebtile wrote:

Hello from my modding queue!

I'm very sorry I only modded the insane diff because I was just really busy and had no time for the Calamity diff. Tests are annoying :/

Insane
• 00:16:137 (4) - Not sure if the clap on this is intentional but if it is, then it just doesn't sound good at all. I suggest you just put the clap on 00:15:987 instead. Oh yeah nice catch
• 00:22:737 (1) - There should be 3 notes instead of this 1/1 slider because there is a sound at 00:22:887. Or you could make a 1/2 reverse slider, whatever you find better. Nah, I can emphasize drums better by omitting the quieter and unnoticeable sounds
• 00:23:787 - You might not agree on me with this one, but there should be a note right here. Although since its a low drum hit, you should make the note a drum and reduce the volume for it. I did it and it sounds perfect. Up to you though. I actually mapped it by NOT mapping it
• 00:24:387 (2) - Same with point 2. (Although this one might be fine because of the high whistle sound in the song)
• 00:25:137 (1) - ^ (This one isn't though)
• 00:30:237 - There should be a note here. Not following the piano like sounds, but the drums in the background. Trying a mapping technique mapping the downbeat as a circle and omitting the eighth following. It works well here
• 00:31:287 (1) - Same with point 2.
• 00:33:687 (1,2) - This overlap is fine but it could be better imo.
• 00:47:487 (1,1) - This overlap could also be better. I messed around a bit, and I found that if you select all 3 notes at 00:47:487 (1,2,3), and then move them to x:84, y:240, the overlap becomes way better. (Visually ofc)
• 00:58:887 (2) - I think that if you NC this, it would be much more fun to play this part in tag-coop. (Yeah I know the slider is short compared to the one next to this one. But still, more fun in tag-coop ^^) Implying anyone plays co-op
• 01:03:687 (2) - ^
• 01:11:337 (1) - There is no need for the NC here. Ok
• 01:27:387 (1) - The random 2.00 SV change here is really awkward to play. I could understand the one at 01:26:787 (1) since it's only 1.5. But a 2.00 SV change just ruins the flow your map had imo. I like how it plays, and the extreme curve slows down the feel significantly
• 01:28:362 (6,7) - This overlap is also fine but it also could have been better.
• From 01:33:687 up until 01:36:912, I think it would sound better if you put drum hitsounds on each slider start and slider end. I experimented with some hitsounds and they all sounded bad
• 01:39:687 (1) - This note should really be a slider like the sliders at 01:39:987 (1,1,1). It should also be mixed up with them. Fits the flow better. o

The rest of this diff is perfectly fine.

Really nice map. And again i'm sorry that I couldn't mod 2 diffs. Good luck on rank.

Shurelia wrote:

00:40:887 (1,2,3,4) - Should be at insane or extra not on hard diff imo.