1. fartownik's Saduharu (4.56 stars, 179 notes)
2. Gintoki (4.98 stars, 233 notes)
3. Kagura (4.39 stars, 144 notes)
4. Shinpachi (2.36 stars, 102 notes)

nante wrote:

Hey, I want to say these all are only suggestions since I'm not experienced and just wanted to help finding you need mod on irc.


Generally:
add "(TV Size)" in the title. yea i will fix that soon, cant believe i forgot >_>

Shinpachi:
00:03:300 (3), 00:05:996 (3), 00:08:693 (3) - I'd like to see those as sliders. It's just a suggestion though. no
00:22:513 (1) - delete new combo no
00:23:187 (2) - add new combo no
00:36:670 (x), 00:42:064 (x) - I feel like playing spinners here. On the other hand, it may be too hard for easy nah not needed
01:17:794 (1) - I'd move this spinner to 01:18:805 (1), then: srry but no again >_>
01:17:794 (2) - add a note ^
01:18:468 (3) - add a note but it may be too hard for an easy difficulty too ^


Kagura:
01:00:434 (1) - this spinner feels a little random yea fixed

Gintoki:
00:16:108 (5) - 1 grid up to make parrel with 4 meh fixed


good luck with the map, star from me

Garven wrote:

Meh, star rating is good enough for the 3.0 recommendation.

[General]
Opening 1 as tags? Eehh. Whatever, hehe. pointless really >_>
Maybe set lead-in time to 1 second? There's a little bit of song in the front so it's not going to hurt much. fixed
Turn off countdown since it's not being used. fixed

[Shinpachi]
00:21:165 (1,2) - I feel that there's more emphasis on these two notes than on 00:22:513 (1) - for a finish use. sry i dont agree
00:45:771 (2) - The endpoints purposefully not aligned? i didnt want too much of a overlap
00:49:479 (2) - A soft finish would be nice on the start of this slider. i see no reason for it
01:04:311 (2) - Scoot this left a grid?
01:04:985 (3) - This up a grid? You'll have to adjust the later combo too if you do these ...thats a half grid movement, beyond even nazi D:
01:10:378 (4) - Down a grid no pointless for a break in the DS
01:11:052 (1) - Left a grid again same
01:11:726 (2) - Turn off grid snap but leave distance snap on when positioning this one, maybe look closer, each of the notes in the combo get a tiny bit extra DS to them , its done on purpose

[Kagura]
00:14:086 (7) - Well, you had mentioned that you wanted to go with the lyrics, so I figured for this difficulty it's easier to justify adding in the extra beats of the voice being held out. Sliders would help emphasize these well. fixed
00:16:783 (5) - ^ fixed
00:19:142 (3) - ^ fixed
01:00:434 (1) - Yeah, you had mentioned that you didn't like it, but I'll just reiterate it. Don't really like this spinner. fixed in a mod before rofl
01:11:726 (2) - Raise a grid? (I love overlap, if you couldn't tell ) no i dont like the closeness it gets to the HP bar then
Kinda hardish, but it works as a good spread between the two other difficulties.

[Gintoki]
dem jumps. ouch.

Great maps!

Lanttu wrote:

[Gintoki]
00:35:659 (1,2,3) - I don't like this giant jump. ;_;
00:41:389 (3,4) - Same here, but maybe reverse the order of 1, 2 and 3? nah
01:20:828 (9) - New combo? it flows to the same style as the pattern after

[Kagura]
00:25:547 (1) - Confusing spacing, maybe move this to where the next 4 is? nah its fine

Starred~ ^^

animask wrote:

[Shinpachi]

Hitsound Suggestions (cuz it needs its own section)

00:02:625 (1,2,3) - Add Finish hitsounds here? no
00:05:322 (1,2,3) - ^ ^
00:08:019 (1,2,3) - ^^
00:11:726 (2) - ^^
00:12:738 (2) - Add a clap at the start
00:13:749 (4) - Clap at end
00:15:434 (2) - Clap
00:16:446 (4) - Clap at end
00:18:131 (3) - Clap
00:19:142 (5) - Clap at end
00:20:828 (3) - Clap no to all
00:21:165 (1,2,1) - Add whistles? no
00:32:962 (1,2,3) - Clap,Whistle,Then Finish hitsound pattern? (2) seems like it could use more emphasis no
00:34:311 (1,2,3) - ^ no
01:05:659 (1) - Finish Hitsound sure

[Kagura]

Hitsound Suggestions

00:16:783 (5) - Finish at end of slider no
00:32:962 (1,1,1) - Add whistles on the first 2 repeats? Also Claps on beginning and end of slider? no
00:38:356 (1,1,1) - ^ no


[Gintoki]

Seems fine.

Starr'd

Also would you accept a taiko map?

XepherX3 wrote:

modding time

[Shinpachi]
add an extra hitcircle on the lalala parts no that would break the vocal

[Gintoki]
video? eh vids working fine?

overall

star able

Fight69 wrote:

Hi there ^^

[General]

As usual, delete the .osb file and full submit. will do that soon

Don't use pure white combo colours, it hurt the eyes, especially during kiai time and this BG, use purple instead ? white stays since it goes with gintoki's hiar
Also, the kiai time is not the same in all diffs and it will stay that way unless fartownik wants to change his

[Gintoki]

Wowow, there is a lot of finishs during kiai time, use less finishs and more claps no

[Kagura]

00:17:457 (1) - It's an evil trap, delete a reverse arrow, add a circle then stack it with the circle (3) no it plays fine

Also, same thing about the finishs during kiai time than Gintoki no

Everything else seems okay.

~Starz'd

Sakura Hana wrote:

[General]
I understand why you are using 1, since i've used it before, however 1 shouldn't be used as a tag, remember that in this setup opening and 1 are different and separate tags, so i recommend you remove 1 from tags. kk sure
Slider tick rate 2 sounds better to me sure
Maybe use combo re-ordering so white combo color never appears during kiai mode? or remove kiai and leave just the fountains, since you dont want to remove white combo color made the white darker

[Gintoki]
00:36:670 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,1,2,3,4) - I recommend you move these notes a bit farther to the upper left to keep the jumps consistent. fixed

[Kagura]
00:44:086 (2,3,4,5) - Instead of flipping the same slider, make them fit perfectly on the outline of the previous one? sure, looks abit wierd but i will go along with it ;p