Guest
home
beatmaps
rankings
community
store
help
forum
  1. Forums
  2. Beatmaps
  3. Ranked Beatmaps (Archived)
  4. Beatmap Graveyard

xi - over the top [OsuMania]

posted
Total Posts
108
ArcherLove
1,434 posts
Joined March 2013
Topic Starter
ArcherLove
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on Thursday, June 29, 2017 at 5:18:42 AM

Artist: xi
Title: over the top
Tags: AD: Nearly 120 seconds Diverse System eternalie ancul
BPM: 202
Filesize: 4076kb
Play Time: 02:00
Difficulties Available:
  1. AncuL's Spesial [SC] - 7Key (6.1 stars, 2498 notes)
  2. Biasa [NM] - 7Key (2.22 stars, 555 notes)
  3. Caramel - 7Key (8.98 stars, 3057 notes)
  4. Ekstrak [EX] - 7Key (7.37 stars, 3549 notes)
  5. Lebih Sulit [IN] - 7Key (4.24 stars, 1292 notes)
  6. Nae's Mudah [EZ] - 7Key (1.45 stars, 365 notes)
  7. Sangat Sulit [MX] - 7Key (5.12 stars, 2053 notes)
  8. Sulit [HD] - 7Key (3.28 stars, 946 notes)
Download: xi - over the top
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
lol redl 4 march 2017 no 7kpress

GD = ancul, eternalie thx
ex = bms
caramel = o2

kini ada [EX]nya
Last edited by ArcherLove , edited 182 times in total.
17VA
1,007 posts
Joined September 2012
17VA
irc mod
SPOILER
00:01 Yooh: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4532678
00:01 ArcherLove: I read it, I will try.. move around..
00:01 ArcherLove: this is hard because many note x_x
00:01 Yooh: ok
00:03 ArcherLove: can you take a look @.@? this is really like.. haaarddd omg
00:03 *ArcherLove is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/902703 xi - over the top [Caramel]]
00:03 ArcherLove: from 01:12:562 - @.@
00:06 ArcherLove: um.. https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4532716 lol this is weeiirdd @.@
00:07 Yooh: emphasis drums with space bar
00:07 Yooh: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4532720
00:08 ArcherLove: this jack is ok? http://puu.sh/n7DFi/f756f0abab.jpg
00:08 Yooh: hmm reverse
00:08 Yooh: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4532727
00:10 ArcherLove: ok
00:11 Yooh: [https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4532742 lol]
00:11 ArcherLove: do you think that can rank?
00:11 ArcherLove: but aa only piano sound www
00:12 Yooh: yeah can rank
00:12 ArcherLove: hmm that only piano based right?
00:13 Yooh: yeah
00:13 ArcherLove: no drum ?
00:15 ArcherLove: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4532765 this no need?
00:15 Yooh: this part is more emphasized by piano 
00:16 Yooh: looks little uncomfortable imo
00:16 ArcherLove: hm
00:16 ArcherLove: ok
00:16 ArcherLove: delete
00:17 ArcherLove: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4532777 this for drum?
00:17 ArcherLove: *kick
00:18 Yooh: hmm...
00:19 ArcherLove: also this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4532788 wwww
00:19 Yooh: I think express only piano is best
00:19 ArcherLove: ah!
00:19 ArcherLove: right
00:19 ArcherLove: 2 part
00:20 ArcherLove: 1 = drum  2 = only piano
00:20 ArcherLove: right
00:20 Yooh: yteah
00:20 Yooh: yeah
00:20 Yooh: I use that gimmicks to avoiding monotonous
00:21 ArcherLove: ok
00:22 ArcherLove: the part after
00:22 ArcherLove: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4532807 like this ok?
00:23 Yooh: yes
00:23 Yooh: much better
00:23 ArcherLove: okeisuu
00:23 ArcherLove: thankss
00:23 ArcherLove: really helpp
00:23 ArcherLove: you can post irc I will give kudos if you want wwwwww
00:23 ArcherLove: this is helpful
Aqo
2,710 posts
Joined April 2010
Aqo
irc mod

SPOILER
17:43 ArcherLove: wa
17:43 ArcherLove: it's really weak sound--
17:44 Aqo: if you really want to emphasize that weak change
17:44 ArcherLove: you were right
17:44 Aqo: then at most do something like this http://i.imgur.com/c4gkMKp.png
17:44 ArcherLove: oh my how in the world you notice that very weak sound
17:44 Aqo: but changing the chord entirely feels wrong
17:44 Aqo: also
17:44 ArcherLove: ok I will do that
17:44 Aqo: I like analyzing a lot of complex songs
17:44 Aqo: lol
17:44 Aqo: so I notice all the little sounds
17:44 ArcherLove: very good ear
17:44 Aqo: I only chart vertically
17:44 ArcherLove: ok I do that
17:45 ArcherLove: I will change all of that kind of sound
17:45 Aqo: ok
17:45 ArcherLove: http://puu.sh/na7PT/422b6ee371.png
17:45 ArcherLove: should I make 4 chord or better 3?
17:45 ArcherLove: at last
17:45 Aqo: I think when making decisions like that
17:45 Aqo: you should take into account relative intensity
17:45 Aqo: and volume
17:46 Aqo: it also depends on the difficulty level you're making
17:46 Aqo: since most of this chart is double streams on this bpm
17:46 Aqo: I'd even use 5 chords
17:46 ArcherLove: hmm since it's only fade sound
17:46 ArcherLove: I think 3 is ok?
17:46 Aqo: also
17:46 Aqo: it gives you a better adjustment range
17:46 Aqo: listen to the difference between
17:47 Aqo: 00:01:275 - and 00:02:166 -
17:47 Aqo: the first one is stronger than the second one
17:47 Aqo: they're mostly the same, but second one has one synth layer at a lower volume
17:47 Aqo: instead of changing the chord like you did
17:47 Aqo: I'd lower the intensity by reducing 1 column
17:47 Aqo: from 5 to 4
17:47 Aqo: and make it 2/3 per hand on first one
17:47 ArcherLove: ah
17:47 Aqo: and 2/2 on second one
17:47 Aqo: to keep the balance for the player
17:47 Aqo: so for example
17:48 Aqo: like this http://i.imgur.com/vDqmk7H.png
17:48 Aqo: that way it doesn't matter if it's right hand or left hand player
17:48 Aqo: the pattern will always feel balanced
17:49 ArcherLove: hmm that's good
17:49 Aqo: while still emphasizing the change in the music
17:49 ArcherLove: ok take
17:49 Aqo: and also being consistent
17:49 Aqo: also
17:49 Aqo: 00:03:354 (3354|2,3502|4) -
17:49 Aqo: those two notes are different in the music
17:49 Aqo: but I'd put them on the same column
17:50 ArcherLove: alright
17:50 Aqo: because they're a completely different rhythm from the louder notes that are present around them
17:50 Aqo: and having variation on the smaller/weaker notes
17:50 Aqo: gives them too much emphasis
17:50 Aqo: it doesn't play as good
17:50 Aqo: also 00:03:651 - and so on
17:50 ArcherLove: roger changed
17:50 Aqo: the loud parts are copy-paste in the music
17:50 Aqo: so I'd also copy paste in the chart
17:50 ArcherLove: I'm working on that
17:50 ArcherLove: hmm
17:51 ArcherLove: I think a bit different but same density would be fine?
17:51 Aqo: it will be fine because that's the first impression the player gets
17:51 Aqo: when you keep it consistent and not random, the player knows very clearly what he's playing
17:51 Aqo: it makes it more fun like that
17:51 Aqo: feels more like you're actually playing the music
17:51 ArcherLove: ah
17:51 ArcherLove: yeah
17:51 Aqo: and not random training patterns
17:51 ArcherLove: it's bms-based chard
17:51 ArcherLove: *chart
17:51 Aqo: yes
17:51 ArcherLove: I should make that way
17:51 Aqo: bms is all about charting the music
17:51 Aqo: the player has to feel
17:51 Aqo: like the music comes out of his fingers
17:52 Aqo: 00:05:730 (5730|2,5730|4) -
17:52 Aqo: two notes for this for example
17:52 Aqo: is a bad idea
17:52 Aqo: there's exactly 1 instrument in use here
17:52 ArcherLove: 4?
17:52 Aqo: no matter how loud or intense it is
17:52 Aqo: I won't use more than 1 note for this
17:52 ArcherLove: should only 1?
17:52 Aqo: yes
17:52 Aqo: there are no layers in the music for this sound
17:53 Aqo: it's a pure single instrument
17:53 ArcherLove: well maybe modder will talk loud about this later but
17:53 ArcherLove: let's just change to 1 right now
17:53 ArcherLove: because this is bms-based
17:53 Aqo: also it feels more fun to play imo
17:53 Aqo: it's more exciting
17:53 ArcherLove: okk
17:53 Aqo: when you have shifts from small into big really fast
17:53 Aqo: keeps you in focus
17:54 Aqo: as for the big stream...
17:54 Aqo: I'm not sure what system you used to place it down
17:54 Aqo: it's hard for me to tell
17:54 Aqo: do you pay attention to blue ticks when placing streams?
17:54 ArcherLove: if 2 note
17:55 ArcherLove: =piano + 1 sound (ckckckck)
17:55 ArcherLove: for chord
17:55 Aqo: I mean position
17:55 ArcherLove: piano+ckck+kick
17:55 ArcherLove: hmm
17:55 Aqo: 00:06:101 (6101|1) - 00:06:250 (6250|5) - 00:06:547 (6547|4) -
17:55 ArcherLove: I guess PR and about simetrical
17:55 Aqo: if you look at just your blue ticks
17:55 ArcherLove: it's like
17:55 ArcherLove: "for playability"
17:55 ArcherLove: since I don't have much experience
17:55 ArcherLove: and when I play it feels nice---
17:55 ArcherLove: orz
17:56 Aqo: they create a shape like this http://i.imgur.com/1484p1i.png
17:56 Aqo: it's kinda random isn't it
17:56 ArcherLove: yeah
17:56 ArcherLove: but I don't think it's weird to play (?)
17:56 ArcherLove: since one of my bms friend said it feels nice
17:56 ArcherLove: idk too
17:56 Aqo: left, right, right, right, right, left, both, both, right, both, middle
17:56 Aqo: the balance here is very inconsistent
17:56 ArcherLove: ;;
17:56 Aqo: did your bms friend FC this?
17:57 Aqo: it's very hard to judge how good a stream pattern plays if you're not FCing it
17:57 Aqo: everything feels "fun" if you're barely surviving on it
17:57 Aqo: but only really well structured maps are fun to play if you're already doing well on them
17:57 ArcherLove: S'd .. at 96%
17:57 Aqo: pro
17:57 Aqo: ;w;
17:58 ArcherLove: and the other one
17:58 ArcherLove: named shadow
17:58 ArcherLove: bmshadow
17:58 Aqo: when I listen to this streamy part of the music
17:58 ArcherLove: only A because can't acc ww
17:58 Aqo: if I were to really simplify the music rhythm here
17:58 Aqo: it sounds like this
17:59 Aqo: http://i.imgur.com/wNoaTCi.png
17:59 Aqo: starting from 00:06:027 -
17:59 ArcherLove: oh that's so like
17:59 Aqo: can you hear this?
17:59 Aqo: there's a constant repeating synth
17:59 ArcherLove: yeah I can
17:59 Aqo: going from red beat to white beat
17:59 ArcherLove: it's the technical way to map
17:59 Aqo: yes
17:59 ArcherLove: but.. it's like
18:00 ArcherLove: killing hand orz
18:00 Aqo: I'm not saying I'll place the notes like this
18:00 ArcherLove: still inexperience with technical thing so I tried a bit 'messy' ones
18:00 Aqo: this is just the base rhythm
18:00 Aqo: now,
18:00 Aqo: if you listen to this rhythm
18:00 Aqo: you notice every 2 white lines
18:00 Aqo: the synth pitch changes
18:00 ArcherLove: yeah
18:00 ArcherLove: higher and higher
18:00 Aqo: and it always changes in the same direction
18:00 Aqo: yes
18:01 ArcherLove: xi style
18:01 Aqo: once you take that into account
18:01 Aqo: http://i.imgur.com/NEZNtcE.png
18:01 Aqo: this is the rhythm here
18:01 Aqo: its basic form
18:01 Aqo: now
18:01 Aqo: look at just the blue ticks
18:01 ArcherLove: okay
18:01 Aqo: the way they gradually move
18:01 Aqo: creates a lot of minitrills
18:02 Aqo: that feel nice to play
18:02 Aqo: it's 'consistent'
18:02 Aqo: but 'different'
18:02 ArcherLove: yes?
18:02 Aqo: hard to explain but like
18:02 Aqo: it plays nice...?
18:02 Aqo: and makes sense with the music
18:02 ArcherLove: hmm right
18:02 Aqo: there's also a drum here on each 1/1
18:02 Aqo: and every 2 white lines another synth
18:03 ArcherLove: thre is part I forgot to put drum at [1] so I change at [7] lol
18:03 Aqo: lol
18:03 ArcherLove: I just kind like mapping while moving
18:03 Aqo: and also if you want another layer
18:03 Aqo: it can follow its own logic
18:03 Aqo: to create a mix for the play
18:03 ArcherLove: higher"
18:03 Aqo: so lets say just regular opposite stair logic
18:03 ArcherLove: following the bass
18:04 Aqo: might be better to do it differently
18:04 Aqo: hmm
18:04 Aqo: for every blue tick on the right
18:04 Aqo: I'd place one on the left
18:04 Aqo: maybe try that
18:05 Aqo: lol zzzz http://i.imgur.com/Hgi0WPh.png
18:05 Aqo: well would need to think about it
18:05 Aqo: either way at this point it's not a suggestion
18:05 Aqo: just saying that the way my mapping system works
18:05 Aqo: I try to take into account both the music and the player's hands
18:05 ArcherLove: yeah yeah it's ok
18:05 Aqo: but I'm having a hard time telling your system on your streams
18:05 ArcherLove: I'm studying any kind of style
18:06 Aqo: it feels kinda random
18:06 ArcherLove: for future purpose
18:06 Aqo: if you run into situations
18:06 Aqo: where you feel like you forgot a note...
18:06 ArcherLove: I already tell my way of mapping is like "mapping while moving"
18:06 Aqo: then imo you should rethink your style
18:06 ArcherLove: yes
18:06 ArcherLove: ?
18:06 Aqo: try to map more vertically
18:06 Aqo: as in
18:06 Aqo: not chronologically
18:06 ArcherLove: well what can I say.. 1st try mapping alone bms..
18:06 Aqo: also try playing a lot of actual bms
18:06 ArcherLove: before, helped by someone (collab) ww
18:06 Aqo: to get ideas
18:07 Aqo: both play and then look at how it looks in the editor
18:09 ArcherLove: my PC broke
18:09 ArcherLove: rip 60gb
18:09 Aqo: 00:15:532 -
18:09 Aqo: back to your map
18:09 Aqo: starting from this point
18:09 ArcherLove: alright
18:09 Aqo: you map double streams
18:09 ArcherLove: PR?
18:09 Aqo: the music is literally
18:09 Aqo: empty
18:09 Aqo: it's just funny
18:10 Aqo: all ghost notes
18:10 Aqo: whhhy
18:10 ArcherLove: aaa
18:10 ArcherLove: 2 note for piano (?)
18:10 ArcherLove: it's like
18:10 ArcherLove: also from bms like
18:10 ArcherLove: doubling sound
18:11 ArcherLove: stuff like that (?)
18:11 Aqo: lol..
18:11 Aqo: this is all the music this part has http://i.imgur.com/5BsmzI7.png
18:11 ArcherLove: if many people against that I don't mind changing it~
18:11 Aqo: well, I'm not against overmapping
18:11 Aqo: but I find it funny how intense you map a calm part of the song
18:12 ArcherLove: aa haha
18:12 ArcherLove: rip ;;
18:12 ArcherLove: I guess
18:12 ArcherLove: for diff purpose (?)
18:12 Aqo: well that goes back to what I said earlier
18:12 Aqo: it makes it feel more like a random pattern training map
18:12 Aqo: than a map for the song
18:13 Aqo: might as well pick your favorite TV size song
18:13 Aqo: and map it the same way
18:13 Aqo: >w<
18:13 ArcherLove: too short
18:13 Aqo: lol
18:13 ArcherLove: I don't really enjoy mapping too short song @.@
18:13 ArcherLove: it's like
18:13 ArcherLove: less creativity
18:13 Aqo: so map the full ver of anime song :b
18:13 ArcherLove: when finish I feel empty
18:13 ArcherLove: TOO LONG
18:13 ArcherLove: sdasdas
18:13 ArcherLove: I'm complicated person /i/
18:14 Aqo: did I send you my 100% magical chart earlier?
18:14 ArcherLove: yes
18:14 *Aqo is listening to Tamura Yukari, Kanai Mika, Horie Yui - 100% Magical Star*
18:14 Aqo: anime short song
18:14 Aqo: also very overmapped
18:14 Aqo: but I don't think it lacks creativity ?_?
18:14 ArcherLove: uh
18:14 Aqo: has lots of variation
18:14 ArcherLove: it's just like self satisfication
18:14 Aqo: even that the music itself is really simple
18:14 Aqo: correct me if I'm wrong
18:14 ArcherLove: yeaah
18:14 Aqo: just saying you don't have to pick a long song
18:15 ArcherLove: but
18:15 Aqo: to find room to mix things up
18:15 ArcherLove: there is some song that's very good
18:15 ArcherLove: so I want to map TV size ww
18:15 Aqo: ww
18:17 Aqo: 01:14:938 -
18:17 Aqo: this part in your chart for example
18:17 Aqo: in the music it's very intense
18:17 Aqo: but in the chart it's low density
18:17 Aqo: compared to other parts you charted with high density like that empty part earlier
18:17 ArcherLove: uhh it's like
18:17 ArcherLove: resting?
18:18 Aqo: resting?
18:18 Aqo: here?
18:18 ArcherLove: you are right
18:18 ArcherLove: let's just
18:18 ArcherLove: not
18:18 ArcherLove: any suggestion?
18:18 Aqo: well
18:18 Aqo: again my overall suggestion for the chart would be
18:18 Aqo: to think about how you can make it vertically
18:19 Aqo: break down the entire song into parts
18:19 Aqo: think which parts feel intense
18:19 Aqo: which parts feel calm
18:19 Aqo: which parts repeat
18:19 Aqo: and which parts have variation in them
18:19 Aqo: and then put patterns accordingly
18:19 Aqo: intense parts get more density
18:19 Aqo: repeat parts get repeat blue ticks to give the player the right feels
18:19 Aqo: calm parts less density
18:19 Aqo: changing parts change the pattern
18:20 Aqo: etc
18:20 ArcherLove: okk
18:20 ArcherLove: ah
18:20 ArcherLove: about this
18:20 Aqo: it's easier to get the right idea when you consider the entire song
18:20 ArcherLove: this is ok? http://puu.sh/na9IO/d49e2486ba.png
18:20 ArcherLove: like
18:20 ArcherLove: vurst
18:20 ArcherLove: *burst
18:20 Aqo: you mean 01:16:423 - right
18:20 ArcherLove: is that kind of pattern acceptable?
18:20 ArcherLove: yes
18:20 Aqo: to be honest
18:20 Aqo: I have noooooooooo idea how to map 1/8 notes
18:21 Aqo: that's one aspect of mapping I have absolutely no idea about
18:21 ArcherLove: uhmm
18:21 Aqo: just do what feels right. it looks okay I guess? lol
18:21 ArcherLove: maybe it's good like this
18:21 ArcherLove: \w/
18:21 Aqo: I think this part
18:21 Aqo: 01:16:683 (76683|2,76720|1,76757|2) -
18:21 Aqo: is annoying to play
18:21 Aqo: would've been better if all 4 stairs faced the same direction imo
18:21 Aqo: that's all I can say
18:22 ArcherLove: ok
18:22 Aqo: playing a jack on yellow ticks
18:22 Aqo: is very hard...
18:22 Aqo: especially with same-hand also doing a stream
18:23 ArcherLove: er..
18:23 ArcherLove: http://puu.sh/na9Rm/81462577f8.jpg ?
18:23 ArcherLove: so wrong--
18:23 ArcherLove: it feels
18:23 Aqo: yeah looks like a mess
18:23 Aqo: uhm
18:25 ArcherLove: lol http://puu.sh/na9Yo/603defe881.jpg
18:25 ArcherLove: spam right left right left
18:25 Aqo: http://i.imgur.com/2MNMEDI.png
18:26 ArcherLove: that's good also
18:27 Aqo: here
18:27 Aqo: http://i.imgur.com/pMnuobO.png
18:27 Aqo: found the right way to balance this
18:28 ArcherLove: oh o.o? I thought this http://puu.sh/naabP/ac94bb519a.jpg good enough?
18:28 ArcherLove: should I change?
18:29 Aqo: it has balance issues
18:29 Aqo: look
18:29 Aqo: http://i.imgur.com/qeq5fEB.png
18:29 ArcherLove: well that's right
18:29 ArcherLove: changing
18:29 Aqo: http://i.imgur.com/nln8Gs3.png
18:29 Aqo: stuff like this feels "weird" when you play it
18:29 Aqo: also
18:29 Aqo: hand balance:
18:29 Aqo: imagine a left-handed player
18:30 ArcherLove: <-
18:30 Aqo: left hand: http://i.imgur.com/g3hh2O8.png
18:30 Aqo: right hand: http://i.imgur.com/wUFUdEt.png
18:30 Aqo: bad hand balance...
18:30 ArcherLove: dead thumb
18:30 ArcherLove: lol tiht
18:30 ArcherLove: *rightt
18:31 Aqo: damnit
18:32 Aqo: you made me think about this song too much
18:32 Aqo: now I want to chart it
18:32 Aqo: zzzz
18:32 ArcherLove: zzzzzzz
18:32 ArcherLove: great song
18:32 ArcherLove: \o\
18:32 Aqo: xi
18:33 ArcherLove: over the top
18:33 Aqo: loll
18:33 Aqo: by the way
18:33 Aqo: remember I told you earlier to use 1 note instead of 2
18:33 ArcherLove: yes?
18:33 Aqo: 01:21:844 (81844|1,81918|2,81992|3) -
18:33 Aqo: in parts like this
18:33 Aqo: I think it's better to unmap
18:33 Aqo: even that the music is there
18:33 Aqo: it makes the transition feel more intense
18:34 ArcherLove: hmm ok
18:34 Aqo: when you keep having 1/4 notes
18:34 Aqo: the player keeps reading at 100% of his attention
18:34 ArcherLove: resting part
18:34 Aqo: so the transition feels weak
18:34 Aqo: but if you put a whole 1/1 gap there
18:34 ArcherLove: okk del
18:34 Aqo: the player's attention drops a little
18:34 Aqo: and then the note on 01:22:067 - feels more intense
18:35 ArcherLove: right
18:35 ArcherLove: great think
18:36 ArcherLove: I should find for more weak transition to make a gap
18:36 ArcherLove: I think none
18:36 ArcherLove: :U
18:37 Aqo: best way to discover those things is just playtest yourself and experiment
18:37 ArcherLove: yup
18:37 ArcherLove: me can't pass
18:37 ArcherLove: not even 1minute
18:37 Aqo: and again... just play many existing popular bms and steal idea
18:37 Aqo: ww
18:37 ArcherLove: ww
18:37 ArcherLove: for now just watch some youtube play
18:37 ArcherLove: and niconico
18:38 ArcherLove: do you want some kudosu? we can mark this as irc
18:38 ArcherLove: I study a lot lol
18:38 Aqo: sure why not :b
18:38 Aqo: it's not really an organized mod tho
18:38 ArcherLove: 1 hour full irc
18:38 ArcherLove: it's ok
18:38 Aqo: lloool
18:38 Aqo: okay 1 hour = 1 kd
18:38 Aqo: xd
18:38 ArcherLove: you gave me many suggestion and it will comes good later /o/
18:38 ArcherLove: rip
18:38 ArcherLove: <_<
18:38 Aqo: I'm looking forward to your charts
18:38 Aqo: :)
18:39 Aqo: just please make playable things too not just impossible stuff haha
18:39 ArcherLove: thank you very much!~
18:39 Aqo: <-- noob. can't play that hard difficulty
18:39 Aqo: x_x
18:39 ArcherLove: I'm always make easier stuff if it's too hard haha
18:39 ArcherLove: maybe I will make 2 Insane
18:39 ArcherLove: well
18:39 ArcherLove: let's just see how it's going
18:39 Aqo: just make things that fit the song
18:39 Aqo: don't think about overall difficutly when mapping
18:39 Aqo: only relative difficulty inside the chart
18:40 Aqo: i.e. intense parts etc
18:40 ArcherLove: okkk
ArcherLove
1,434 posts
Joined March 2013
Topic Starter
ArcherLove


Aqo et.

lol
23:51 ArcherLove: yepp ok
23:52 ArcherLove: aqo jack 1/3 202 bpm at MX 
23:52 ArcherLove: is it ok?
23:52 ArcherLove: (first intro over the top)
23:53 Aqo: orz the savelog didn't catch everything
23:53 Aqo: ummm "is it okay"?
23:53 Aqo: the answer is "it depends..."?
23:53 ArcherLove: too long chat
23:53 Aqo: just try playing it...
23:53 Aqo: see for yourself
23:53 Aqo: hard to answer without playtesting...
23:53 ArcherLove: uhh
23:53 ArcherLove: too pro for playing ez stuff 8)
23:53 *ArcherLove killed
23:53 Aqo: PLS
23:53 Aqo: PLSSSSSSS
23:53 Aqo: Woooooow
23:54 Aqo: xD
23:54 ArcherLove: yeaaaaaaahhhhhhhh
Yanamon
46 posts
Joined May 2013
Yanamon
00:48:205 (48205|0,48279|0) - mini jack nyempil sebiji, delete ae, mngkn kea gini? http://imgur.com/ahJaMNn

01:13:750 (73750|1,73750|6,73750|0,73750|3,73750|4,73824|2,73824|5,73898|3,73973|4,74047|5,74121|4,74195|3,74270|2,74344|1,74418|3,74492|4,74567|5,74641|1,74715|2,74789|3,74864|4) - terlalu ez LN wall nye, ma stairny kurang cocok ma tangga nada(?), saran seh kya gni : http://imgur.com/scmkSVe

00:16:720 DKK, bagusan yg sblmnya (bukan LN wall) IMO
XeoStyle
390 posts
Joined October 2013
XeoStyle
meow
23:51 XeoStyle: 00:59:492 (59492|5,60680|4,60680|6,60755|5,60829|4,60903|5,60977|6) -
23:51 XeoStyle: this thing is annoying to play
23:51 ArcherLove: hmm
23:52 ArcherLove: let me change the LN to the 7
23:52 XeoStyle: good idee
23:52 ArcherLove: is this good?http://puu.sh/ncYNh/2ada29b696.jpg
23:53 XeoStyle: [https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4561153 what about this ?]
23:54 ArcherLove: alright http://puu.sh/ncYSM/7c7d1d64c9.jpg ??
23:54 XeoStyle: ye, this pattern play good actually
23:55 ArcherLove: alright, anything else .w.?
23:56 XeoStyle: 01:16:126 -
23:57 XeoStyle: this part is uuuh :/
23:57 ArcherLove: I think that part plays well (?)
23:58 XeoStyle: for a MX level player like me, not really :/
23:58 XeoStyle: maybe ask some good 7k mappers, i'm not really good at modding 7k too x)
23:58 XeoStyle: like PyaKura <:
23:58 ArcherLove: hmm
23:58 XeoStyle: hmmmhmmhmhmm
23:59 ArcherLove: I need to make another bms-based style for filling gap between SHD and UHD I guess
23:59 ArcherLove: so people will enjoy all X diff (?)
23:59 ArcherLove: and another MX..?
23:59 ArcherLove: asdasd
23:59 XeoStyle: Some harder bms diff looks like a good idee
00:00 ArcherLove: Extra is a overjoy 3 though
00:00 ArcherLove: btw http://puu.sh/ncZen/afe910df28.jpg this is ok?
00:00 XeoStyle: where ?
00:01 XeoStyle: time pls
00:01 XeoStyle: x)
00:08 ArcherLove: hm
00:08 ArcherLove: sorry
00:08 ArcherLove: doing home chores aasd
00:08 ArcherLove: the part before
00:08 ArcherLove: when you said "not good for player MX like me"
00:08 ArcherLove: 01:16:200
00:08 ArcherLove: 01:16:200 -\
00:17 XeoStyle: OH
00:17 XeoStyle: sorry i'm gonna look right meow
00:17 ArcherLove: .
00:17 ArcherLove: haha
00:17 ArcherLove: my bad for suddenly afk asdasd
00:18 XeoStyle: yeah
00:18 XeoStyle: I kinda prefer this
00:19 ArcherLove: alright
00:19 ArcherLove: 'w')b
00:19 XeoStyle: 01:16:794 (76794|4) - to 2 ?
00:20 ArcherLove: ok
00:21 XeoStyle: humm
00:22 XeoStyle: 01:19:839 note here no ?
00:22 XeoStyle: 01:19:839- *
00:22 XeoStyle: 01:19:839 -
00:23 ArcherLove: 'w'
00:23 ArcherLove: 01:19:839 -
00:23 ArcherLove: oh
00:23 ArcherLove: I only focus on piano on that part
00:23 ArcherLove: since 01:24:591 (84591|3) - it is the reff part so
00:24 XeoStyle: okok
00:25 XeoStyle: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4561276 and https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4561285
00:25 XeoStyle: ?
00:25 XeoStyle: the trill plays really good
00:26 XeoStyle: oh you map it after
00:26 XeoStyle: my bad
00:26 XeoStyle: I'm not familliar with your mapping style my bad
00:26 XeoStyle: x)
00:27 ArcherLove: alright
00:27 ArcherLove: it's good
00:27 ArcherLove: it's still following the piano <_<
00:27 ArcherLove: why not lol
00:27 ArcherLove: since I mapped it apparently 01:38:997 (98997|3,99072|6,99146|3,99220|6) -
00:28 XeoStyle: yeah thats what I was saying :P
00:29 XeoStyle: everything is good for me
00:29 XeoStyle: I'm not a pro modder too, sorry, but I really enjoy the MX
00:29 XeoStyle: it's really fun with random :D
00:30 ArcherLove: alright XD
00:30 ArcherLove: thank you`
00:30 ArcherLove: if you want some kudos you can post @ thread :>
00:30 XeoStyle: maybe for the intro
00:31 XeoStyle: you can add a not for the cymbals
00:31 XeoStyle: or remove a note for every non-cymbal note
00:31 ArcherLove: um which one?
00:31 XeoStyle: 00:03:651 (3651|0) - like here
00:31 XeoStyle: or here 00:01:275 (1275|3) -
00:32 ArcherLove: oh the jack
00:32 ArcherLove: it's like
00:32 ArcherLove: hand balance
00:32 ArcherLove: I'd rather keep that owo
00:32 XeoStyle: I don't think adding one note is gonna destroy your hand balance
00:32 XeoStyle: anyway, as you want :P
00:33 ArcherLove: oh
00:33 ArcherLove: adding
00:33 ArcherLove: adding where O.O
00:33 XeoStyle: yeah
00:33 XeoStyle: for the cymbals
00:33 ArcherLove: 4 note?
00:33 XeoStyle: [00:01:275 (1275|5,1275|3,1275|0) - here] and [00:03:651 (3651|0,3651|3,3651|5) - here]
00:33 XeoStyle: rip link
00:34 XeoStyle: yeah 4 notes
00:34 XeoStyle: I think it's ok since the section is based on 3 notes for all the others
00:34 ArcherLove: lool
00:34 XeoStyle: 4 notes is gonna add some consistency for the section
00:34 ArcherLove: alright
00:34 XeoStyle: for the cymbal :D
00:35 ArcherLove: adding all for that part
00:35 XeoStyle: Do the same for the others ones too :D
00:35 ArcherLove: already
00:35 XeoStyle: good
00:36 XeoStyle: Ok, i'm gonna post the logz
00:36 ArcherLove: okk
00:36 XeoStyle: because yaykudoxdlolswag
00:36 ArcherLove: lolol
DeletedUser_259972
DeletedUser_259972
If this become ranked...
Forget maniera
Forget 2006
Forget the limit does not exist
This is real pp



I think offset 1291 is more correct
all mods are written after applying offset 1291, so apply offset first and then take mods

also, make sure to add kiai time somewhere
I suggest 00:34:558 - ~ 00:53:552 - / 01:22:067 - ~ 01:55:334 - (you can disable kiai time in 01:36:027 - ~ 01:36:324 - if you want)

Extra


  1. General pattern: I think cobweb is too overused. Try moving some column to remove cobweb patterns.
  2. 00:02:182 (2182|5,2182|1,2182|6,2182|3,2281|3,2281|1,2281|6,2281|5,2380|6,2380|5,2380|3,2380|1,2479|3,2479|0,2479|6) - 5 notes, since everything else is 5 notes
    00:04:558 (4558|5,4558|3,4558|1,4558|6,4657|5,4657|6,4657|1,4657|3,4756|3,4756|6,4756|5,4756|1,4855|3,4855|6,4855|0) - ^
  3. 00:05:746 (5746|4) - Double maybe?
  4. 00:33:964 (33964|2,33964|0,33964|6,34001|5,34038|4,34075|3,34112|2,34112|0,34131|3,34149|4,34168|5,34187|6,34205|1,34224|2,34242|3,34261|6,34261|0,34261|4) - I think this is 1/6 snap, and also piano goes until 00:34:558 -
  5. 00:53:568 - ~ 00:58:320 - How about filling every 1/4 snap? This is piano part
  6. 01:03:073 - note is missing
  7. 01:03:964 (63964|3,63964|6,63964|1,63964|5,64063|5,64063|6,64063|1,64063|3,64162|1,64162|3,64162|5,64162|6,64261|3,64261|6,64261|0) - 5 notes also
    01:06:340 (66340|5,66340|1,66340|6,66340|3,66439|3,66439|1,66439|6,66439|5,66538|6,66538|5,66538|3,66538|1,66637|3,66637|0,66637|6) - ^
    01:08:716 (68716|3,68716|6,68716|1,68716|5,68815|5,68815|6,68815|1,68815|3,68914|1,68914|3,68914|5,68914|6,69013|3,69013|6,69013|0) - ^
  8. 01:11:984 (71984|6,71984|0,71984|4,72058|1,72132|5,72132|2,72206|3) - Ctrl+H? (left hand is too busier than right hand)
  9. 01:14:954 - ~ 01:16:439 - I think this part should be 1/8 snap too
  10. 01:26:315 - 01:26:464 - 01:26:687 - add some more note, since this is drum sound
  11. 01:53:865 (113865|2,113865|0,113865|5,113865|3,113939|4,113939|1) - 1/8 snap
  12. 01:54:756 (114756|5,114756|0,114756|3,114756|6,114756|2,114830|4,114830|1,114904|2,114904|6,114979|1,114979|5) - ^
  13. again, too much cobweb. :o

UHD


  1. 00:03:568 (3568|4) - Move to 00:03:518 -
  2. 00:05:300 (5300|2,5375|4,5523|6) - Weird timing, perhaps move all to 1/2 snap?
  3. 00:29:880 - piano is hearable here.
  4. 01:26:390 (86390|4,86390|3) - Move to 01:26:315 -
  5. 01:45:399 (105399|5,105399|0) - Move to 01:45:325 -
Will this be ranked? I'm not sure.
But GL anyways! :)
ArcherLove
1,434 posts
Joined March 2013
Topic Starter
ArcherLove

jakads wrote:

If this become ranked...
Forget maniera
Forget 2006
Forget the limit does not exist
This is real pp



I think offset 1291 is more correct
all mods are written after applying offset 1291, so apply offset first and then take mods

also, make sure to add kiai time somewhere
I suggest 00:34:558 - ~ 00:53:552 - / 01:22:067 - ~ 01:55:334 - (you can disable kiai time in 01:36:027 - ~ 01:36:324 - if you want)

Extra


  1. General pattern: I think cobweb is too overused. Try moving some column to remove cobweb patterns.
  2. 00:02:182 (2182|5,2182|1,2182|6,2182|3,2281|3,2281|1,2281|6,2281|5,2380|6,2380|5,2380|3,2380|1,2479|3,2479|0,2479|6) - 5 notes, since everything else is 5 notes
    00:04:558 (4558|5,4558|3,4558|1,4558|6,4657|5,4657|6,4657|1,4657|3,4756|3,4756|6,4756|5,4756|1,4855|3,4855|6,4855|0) - ^
  3. 00:05:746 (5746|4) - Double maybe? //// there is only 1 sound so.. maybe later~
  4. 00:33:964 (33964|2,33964|0,33964|6,34001|5,34038|4,34075|3,34112|2,34112|0,34131|3,34149|4,34168|5,34187|6,34205|1,34224|2,34242|3,34261|6,34261|0,34261|4) - I think this is 1/6 snap, and also piano goes until 00:34:558 -
  5. 00:53:568 - ~ 00:58:320 - How about filling every 1/4 snap? This is piano part
  6. 01:03:073 - note is missing
  7. 01:03:964 (63964|3,63964|6,63964|1,63964|5,64063|5,64063|6,64063|1,64063|3,64162|1,64162|3,64162|5,64162|6,64261|3,64261|6,64261|0) - 5 notes also
    01:06:340 (66340|5,66340|1,66340|6,66340|3,66439|3,66439|1,66439|6,66439|5,66538|6,66538|5,66538|3,66538|1,66637|3,66637|0,66637|6) - ^
    01:08:716 (68716|3,68716|6,68716|1,68716|5,68815|5,68815|6,68815|1,68815|3,68914|1,68914|3,68914|5,68914|6,69013|3,69013|6,69013|0) - ^
  8. 01:11:984 (71984|6,71984|0,71984|4,72058|1,72132|5,72132|2,72206|3) - Ctrl+H? (left hand is too busier than right hand)
  9. 01:14:954 - ~ 01:16:439 - I think this part should be 1/8 snap too
  10. 01:26:315 - 01:26:464 - 01:26:687 - add some more note, since this is drum sound
  11. 01:53:865 (113865|2,113865|0,113865|5,113865|3,113939|4,113939|1) - 1/8 snap
  12. 01:54:756 (114756|5,114756|0,114756|3,114756|6,114756|2,114830|4,114830|1,114904|2,114904|6,114979|1,114979|5) - ^
  13. again, too much cobweb. :o

UHD


  1. 00:03:568 (3568|4) - Move to 00:03:518 -
  2. 00:05:300 (5300|2,5375|4,5523|6) - Weird timing, perhaps move all to 1/2 snap? ///// I change to only 1/4 hehe
  3. 00:29:880 - piano is hearable here.
  4. 01:26:390 (86390|4,86390|3) - Move to 01:26:315 -
  5. 01:45:399 (105399|5,105399|0) - Move to 01:45:325 -
Will this be ranked? I'm not sure.
But GL anyways! :)
thank you jakads!~ no reply means ok!
Kenny-sama
196 posts
Joined August 2015
Kenny-sama
Good luck :D
Critical_Star
Beatmap Nominator
1,210 posts
Joined December 2013
Critical_Star
Hi Archer! just a quick mod passing by ;w;

column 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Nae's EZ
00:32:776 - add for crash? just like 00:33:370 (33370|1) -
00:34:261 - this sound are really loud and obvious, add a note?
00:55:647 - 00:58:023 - i guess is fine to have a note here too, it play nicely here
01:49:706 - stopped follow kick?
01:55:350 (115350|1,115350|0) - should be single note like 01:17:033 (77033|5) -


NM
00:50:003 - double note here for crash?
00:52:677 - 00:53:271 - add a note for crash?
00:58:320 - 00:59:508 - 01:00:696 - ^
01:10:201 - 01:11:390 - ^ oh all intention not to add? because all is just the same like 01:14:954 (74954|3) -
01:21:489 (81489|1) - actually the LN sound should end 01:21:489 (81489|1) -
01:25:276 (85276|1) - wrong placement? lol
01:36:043 (96043|2) - remove? since there is no kick sound there which u are following


HD
00:25:053 - start here, is it me or the double and single note placement are reversed? example 00:25:350 - here should be double and 00:25:647 - single?

IN
(some part are just like in HD before, kinda reverse placement of double and single :x)
00:14:657 (14657|2,14731|3,14805|4,14880|5) - if u are following these 1/4 sound stream then u should add at previous part too http://puu.sh/nduGM/f776a60ba9.png
00:15:251 - add a note here for kick?
00:43:172 - 00:46:142 - add a note?

i guess that it qwq Good Luck for it~ :)
AncuL
1,114 posts
Joined March 2013
AncuL
AncuL's SHD newer AncuL's SHD
old SHD -> VHD (Very Hard)
Last edited by AncuL , edited 1 time in total.
Pizza
327 posts
Joined March 2015
Pizza
Ijin nembak :v
AncuL
1,114 posts
Joined March 2013
AncuL

Pizza wrote:

Ijin nembak :v
udah abis

suggestion:

EZ-NM-HD-IN-MX-SC-EX-ULT-VHD-SHD-UHD (?)
ArcherLove
1,434 posts
Joined March 2013
Topic Starter
ArcherLove

Critical_Star wrote:

Hi Archer! just a quick mod passing by ;w;

column 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Nae's EZ
00:32:776 - add for crash? just like 00:33:370 (33370|1) -
00:34:261 - this sound are really loud and obvious, add a note?
00:55:647 - 00:58:023 - i guess is fine to have a note here too, it play nicely here
01:49:706 - stopped follow kick?
01:55:350 (115350|1,115350|0) - should be single note like 01:17:033 (77033|5) -


NM
00:50:003 - double note here for crash?
00:52:677 - 00:53:271 - add a note for crash?
00:58:320 - 00:59:508 - 01:00:696 - ^
01:10:201 - 01:11:390 - ^ oh all intention not to add? because all is just the same like 01:14:954 (74954|3) -
01:21:489 (81489|1) - actually the LN sound should end 01:21:489 (81489|1) - ///////wheereee??
01:25:276 (85276|1) - wrong placement? lol
01:36:043 (96043|2) - remove? since there is no kick sound there which u are following


HD
00:25:053 - start here, is it me or the double and single note placement are reversed? example 00:25:350 - here should be double and 00:25:647 - single?

IN
(some part are just like in HD before, kinda reverse placement of double and single :x)
00:14:657 (14657|2,14731|3,14805|4,14880|5) - if u are following these 1/4 sound stream then u should add at previous part too http://puu.sh/nduGM/f776a60ba9.png
00:15:251 - add a note here for kick?
00:43:172 - 00:46:142 - add a note?

i guess that it qwq Good Luck for it~ :)
thank you all without reply applied and fixed~
Fubukicat
970 posts
Joined February 2012
Fubukicat

Critical_Star wrote:

Hi Archer! just a quick mod passing by ;w;

column 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Nae's EZ
00:32:776 - add for crash? just like 00:33:370 (33370|1) - Keep , I think it's okay to not double this one since it's not that loud imho
00:34:261 - this sound are really loud and obvious, add a note?
00:55:647 - 00:58:023 - i guess is fine to have a note here too, it play nicely here Really cool flow nice find
01:49:706 - stopped follow kick? nice catch
01:55:350 (115350|1,115350|0) - should be single note like 01:17:033 (77033|5) - owob

i guess that it qwq Good Luck for it~ :)
Tanks for mod :3
Update des

Nae > Etlie , xd just wanted to change ;w;
Comet_M
89 posts
Joined May 2014
Comet_M
Hello ArcherLove! (from modding queue ;p)

Column : 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7

Feel free to reject my suggestion, but please explain the reason!

Mods
Nae's EZ

- 01:35:449 (95449|3) - Add note? There's a crash sound here, too. Like this ; 01:35:152 (95152|3,95152|0)


NM

- 00:06:043 (6043|4) - Add note? It has pretty relatively strong drumkick. -- 00:06:340 (6340|4) - Move to 6
- 00:40:795 (40795|4), 00:41:390 (41390|2) - Add note? For drumkick consistency. -- 00:41:687 (41687|2) - Move to 4
- 00:48:518 (48518|0) - Add note? Same reason with ^^^
- 00:50:003 (50003|0) - Add note? There's a crash sound here. Maybe need relatively loud hitsound.
- 01:17:330 (77330|4,77330|6) ~ 01:17:330 (77330|4,77330|6) - Too few notes among all song. Is it intentional?
- 01:51:934 (111934|6,112231|6,112528|6,112825|6) - Move to 7? Jack with 01:50:597 (110597|4) can be pretty challenging for NM players. -- 01:52:974 (112974|5) - Move to 5 -- 01:53:271 (113271|3) - Move to 3


HD

- 00:48:815 (48815|4,48815|0) ~ 00:51:191 (51191|3,51191|5) - Relatively easier than the stream from 00:53:568 (53568|5). http://puu.sh/ndwhT/5a0a58a886.png ?


IN

- 00:06:043 (6043|0) ~ 00:14:360 (14360|1,14360|6) - Fewer notes than HD. Hmm?
- 00:24:756 (24756|4) - Add LN here? (or at 1) There's a recycle-sound (what should I call it ;p) like HD.
- 00:39:607 (39607|5,39607|1) ~ 00:40:498 (40498|3) - Pretty simple. I suggest this : http://puu.sh/ndwKv/858cb8e80e.png
- 00:50:152 (50152|5) - Add note? -- 00:50:449 (50449|5) - Add note?
- 00:50:449 (50449|5) ~ 01:51:786 (111786|6,111786|4,111786|2) - Empty right-hand notes on purpose? (I suggest Ctrl+H to these 01:51:191 (111191|0,111340|1,111489|2))


MX

- 00:47:033 (47033|6) - Add note to 7? Consistency + pretty empty right-side.
- 01:26:315 (86315|6) - Add note to 7? Drumkick here. Listen carefully!
- 01:31:068 (91068|4) - Add note to 5? Same as ^^^
- 01:45:325 (105325|6) - Add note to 7? Same as ^^^ -- 01:45:474 (105474|6) - Move to 6
- 01:51:860 (111860|5) - Add note to 6? 01:50:672 (110672|3) - Here exists a note, but there isn't. I think those two have same melody-proceeding.


SC

- 00:26:761 (26761|1,26835|2,26909|3,26984|4) - Move those all 1 column left. Like these ; 00:29:211 (29211|6,29286|5,29360|4,29434|3)
- 00:39:459 (39459|1) - Add note to 2? 6 alone is pretty awkward for me.
- 00:41:835 (41835|6) - Add note to 7? Same as ^^^
- 01:26:315 (86315|5) - Add note to 6? Drumkick-sound here.
- 01:32:553 (92553|6) - Blue note on purpose? I thought it should be on red, :roll:


VHD

- 00:53:568 (53568|6) - I suggest to put 'normal note' instead of LN.


AncuL's SHD

- 01:10:647 (70647|2) - Is this a blank sound? Maybe add note to 3, here.
- 01:35:969 (95969|2,95969|3,96043|1,96043|5,96043|6) - http://puu.sh/ndxN0/1980d24f57.png ?


Extra

- 01:53:865 (113865|2,113865|6) - Pretty tricky -- http://puu.sh/ndxXI/47df697786.png ?
- 02:00:102 (120102|0) - Add note to 1?


UHD

- 01:24:385 (84385|4) - Move to 3?
- 01:35:969 (95969|3) - Add note to 4? Need pretty loud sound with high-pitched ;p


Caramel

- 01:17:033 (77033|1,77107|2,77182|3,77256|4) - Intentional 1/12 snapped LN?
- 01:21:526 (81526|2,81600|1,81674|2,81748|1) - Ctrl+J ?

Fewer mods in challenging difficulties than EZ ~ IN..

Good luck with your Beatmap! I hope this get ranked ;)
Last edited by Comet_M , edited 1 time in total.
Fubukicat
970 posts
Joined February 2012
Fubukicat
Dadon~
hope this can help

9Mod9
Keys collumn = 1/2/3/4/5/6/7
[Caramel]
00:19:038 (19038|2) - I think it would be easier in term of reading if that LN ends here : 00:19:112 - I think it's weird if that start on blue line but keep going on next section
^ 00:16:736 (16736|5) - and 00:21:489 (21489|5) - are the respective parts before and after and you dosn't seems to make LNs holding after the white line there
00:28:543 (28543|6) - Same suggestion , it would be easier to make it end here : 00:28:617 -
00:38:493 - add another note for the piano (you could also consider the piano as one simple note and then you can just keep it one note)
[UHD]
00:36:489 (36489|3,36489|0) - I suggest moving thoose to : 00:36:637 - to follow piano instead , could make a great rythm to play imho
00:45:993 (45993|6,45993|4,45993|2) - I suggest making thoose only Simple instead of LNs , reason is cause you Layer Piano as LN and this notes are drum
^however 00:46:142 (46142|3,46142|0) - thoose ones are piano so they should be LNs
[IN]
02:00:102 (120102|3) - move to 5 ?
[NM]
01:51:934 (111934|4,112528|4) - I suggest moving thoose note to another collumn the shielding is quite hard for newcomer imo and then you can still same collumn the 3 other notes I think.

here goes :'

@CometicRush Not adding here cause of triple chords , one single is fine in between imho
Rido
812 posts
Joined April 2014
Rido
we have too much ULTRA here!!11! rank plss!!11!!
Raediaufar
879 posts
Joined November 2014
Raediaufar
found this map on the group (fb promotion lol) just check this map a while, noticing some wrong things

- Lots of stacked objects in UHD diffs

UHD:
00:43:914 - add 67 for kick here?
01:19:706 (79706|5,79706|1,79706|2,79706|6) - maybe just three notes because it's low sound

not a full modding but just quick check, do not kds if it's not helpful
ArcherLove
1,434 posts
Joined March 2013
Topic Starter
ArcherLove

CometicRush wrote:

Hello ArcherLove! (from modding queue ;p)

Column : 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7

Feel free to reject my suggestion, but please explain the reason!

Mods
Nae's EZ

- 01:35:449 (95449|3) - Add note? There's a crash sound here, too. Like this ; 01:35:152 (95152|3,95152|0)


NM

- 00:06:043 (6043|4) - Add note? It has pretty relatively strong drumkick. -- 00:06:340 (6340|4) - Move to 6
- 00:40:795 (40795|4), 00:41:390 (41390|2) - Add note? For drumkick consistency. -- 00:41:687 (41687|2) - Move to 4
- 00:48:518 (48518|0) - Add note? Same reason with ^^^
- 00:50:003 (50003|0) - Add note? There's a crash sound here. Maybe need relatively loud hitsound. /// it's NM so.. maybe enough ww
- 01:17:330 (77330|4,77330|6) ~ 01:17:330 (77330|4,77330|6) - Too few notes among all song. Is it intentional? ////// NM DIFF~~
- 01:51:934 (111934|6,112231|6,112528|6,112825|6) - Move to 7? Jack with 01:50:597 (110597|4) can be pretty challenging for NM players. -- 01:52:974 (112974|5) - Move to 5 -- 01:53:271 (113271|3) - Move to 3


HD

- 00:48:815 (48815|4,48815|0) ~ 00:51:191 (51191|3,51191|5) - Relatively easier than the stream from 00:53:568 (53568|5). http://puu.sh/ndwhT/5a0a58a886.png ? ncie~ but I like LN more ww


IN

- 00:06:043 (6043|0) ~ 00:14:360 (14360|1,14360|6) - Fewer notes than HD. Hmm?
- 00:24:756 (24756|4) - Add LN here? (or at 1) There's a recycle-sound (what should I call it ;p) like HD. /////// I think 1 LN enough ww
- 00:39:607 (39607|5,39607|1) ~ 00:40:498 (40498|3) - Pretty simple. I suggest this : http://puu.sh/ndwKv/858cb8e80e.png /// re arrange~
- 00:50:152 (50152|5) - Add note? -- 00:50:449 (50449|5) - Add note?
- 00:50:449 (50449|5) ~ 01:51:786 (111786|6,111786|4,111786|2) - Empty right-hand notes on purpose? (I suggest Ctrl+H to these 01:51:191 (111191|0,111340|1,111489|2))


MX

- 00:47:033 (47033|6) - Add note to 7? Consistency + pretty empty right-side.
- 01:26:315 (86315|6) - Add note to 7? Drumkick here. Listen carefully!
- 01:31:068 (91068|4) - Add note to 5? Same as ^^^
- 01:45:325 (105325|6) - Add note to 7? Same as ^^^ -- 01:45:474 (105474|6) - Move to 6
- 01:51:860 (111860|5) - Add note to 6? 01:50:672 (110672|3) - Here exists a note, but there isn't. I think those two have same melody-proceeding.


SC

- 00:26:761 (26761|1,26835|2,26909|3,26984|4) - Move those all 1 column left. Like these ; 00:29:211 (29211|6,29286|5,29360|4,29434|3) ////re-arrange~
- 00:39:459 (39459|1) - Add note to 2? 6 alone is pretty awkward for me. /// to 4~
- 00:41:835 (41835|6) - Add note to 7? Same as ^^^
- 01:26:315 (86315|5) - Add note to 6? Drumkick-sound here.
- 01:32:553 (92553|6) - Blue note on purpose? I thought it should be on red, :roll:


VHD

- 00:53:568 (53568|6) - I suggest to put 'normal note' instead of LN.


AncuL's SHD

- 01:10:647 (70647|2) - Is this a blank sound? Maybe add note to 3, here.
- 01:35:969 (95969|2,95969|3,96043|1,96043|5,96043|6) - http://puu.sh/ndxN0/1980d24f57.png ?


Extra

- 01:53:865 (113865|2,113865|6) - Pretty tricky -- http://puu.sh/ndxXI/47df697786.png ?
- 02:00:102 (120102|0) - Add note to 1? ////overnote~~


UHD

- 01:24:385 (84385|4) - Move to 3?
- 01:35:969 (95969|3) - Add note to 4? Need pretty loud sound with high-pitched ;p


Caramel

- 01:17:033 (77033|1,77107|2,77182|3,77256|4) - Intentional 1/12 snapped LN? /////yes
- 01:21:526 (81526|2,81600|1,81674|2,81748|1) - Ctrl+J ?

Fewer mods in challenging difficulties than EZ ~ IN..

Good luck with your Beatmap! I hope this get ranked ;)
all eter mod applied also UPDATED

edit : and this guy above me applied
Last edited by ArcherLove , edited 2 times in total.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply

0
1 / 108