1. Futsuu (2.36 stars, 522 notes)
2. Kantan (1.74 stars, 333 notes)
3. Muzukashii (3.21 stars, 889 notes)
4. Oni (4.35 stars, 1213 notes)

1. 00:14:155 (32) - ctrl+g with next note
   
   
2. 00:24:861 (63) - k
   
   
3. 01:25:158 (227) - kk d
   
   
4. 01:45:675 (273) - K
   
   
5. 01:46:287 (274) - dkddkkdk or dkddkkkd
   
   
6. 01:49:042 (282) - d kk k k d d k d d k
   
   
7. 02:45:665 (437) - Move to 02:45:512 (so pattern is dd d, not d dd)
   
   
8. 03:06:506 (492) - k
   
   
9. 00:00:000 (0) - Just a general comment, be careful with the length of the patterns, as many of them seem rather long for Futsuu (and it confuses the star rating lol)

1. 00:01:586 (2) - k (and this goes for every other instance of this pattern)
   
   
2. 00:12:619 (49) - kkdd kdk (or just invert it abekobe style lol)
   
   
3. 00:14:002 (56) - ctrl+g with next note
   
   
4. 00:15:685 (63) - d
   
   
5. 00:23:943 (103) - ctrl+g with next note
   
   
6. 00:33:739 (148) - ^
   
   
7. 00:45:205 (195) - dkkdk k
   
   
8. 00:50:868 (223) - Move to 00:50:715
   
   
9. 00:52:399 (231) - dkkdk
   
   
10. 01:12:920 (334) - dk
    
    
11. 01:44:144 (467) - kkd
    
    
12. 02:16:286 (610) - Same change as 00:50:868
    
    
13. 02:54:567 (813) - kkdk dkk kd kkdd
    
    
14. 03:06:046 (872) - k

1. 00:01:586 (2) - Same as Muzu
   
   
2. 01:32:205 (565) - k
   
   
3. 02:09:858 (747) - d
   
   
4. 00:00:000 (0) - Skeuddy already said all my other stuff lol

1. Do you really need to change BPM in many places? This song has already Ranked mapset. not TV size. How about this for reference? https://osu.ppy.sh/s/59269
   Edit : In last part, probably you are correct lol
2. Disable to Widescreen Support.

1. 02:33:123 (259) - move to 02:32:970 - ? In every this part, you put on 1/2 tick.

1. 03:15:846 (1) - Why is shorter than Kantan? Do you extend it to 03:20:027 - ?

1. 00:08:388 (34) - move to 00:08:542 - ? If you follow drm rhythm, sounds better I think.
2. 00:15:685 (63) - change to d? Because of guitar sound pitch.
3. 00:23:178 (100) - change to d? Maybe you followed vocal sounds, but I think vocal pitch turn up or turn(?) down 00:23:331 (101) - .
4. 00:28:994 - add d? You can follow a vocal sound.
5. 00:34:198 (151) - delete? You can make 3/2 break. Also I can prevent you from putting it on with a pattern 00:33:433 (147,148,149,150) - .
6. 00:41:851 (184) - change to k? When I consider a vocal sound. Now k kdd k kdd k kdd... repeat is okay...
7. 00:46:735 (204) - change to d? Maybe you consider a guitar sound, but if you changed, more fit I think.
8. 00:46:888 (205) - change to k? Because of vocal 00:46:123 (201) -
9. 00:55:919 (250) - change to k? Because of vocal too.
10. 01:12:155 (332) - d? same as 00:23:178 -
11. 01:17:968 - add k? same as 00:28:994 -
12. 02:22:715 - add k? You can follow a drum sound, also I think is better.
13. 03:15:693 (923) - change to d? Because of guitar sound pitch.

1. 00:14:614 (80) - change to d? If you follow a drum sound, sounds better.
2. 00:39:096 (240) - change to d? Because of vocal sound.
3. 01:23:627 (515) - change to k? same reason.

SKSalt wrote:

Hi, Taiko mod request from my queue.

[General]

1. Do you really need to change BPM in many places? This song has already Ranked mapset. not TV size. How about this for reference? https://osu.ppy.sh/s/59269
   Edit : In last part, probably you are correct lol No, just because the mapset is very old and the bpm isn't really fit for Taiko, that why I find Charles to get better bpm or offset to me.
2. Disable to Widescreen Support. Since the BG is widescreen so I guess it's no need to disable it

[Kantan]

1. 02:33:123 (259) - move to 02:32:970 - ? In every this part, you put on 1/2 tick. But I'm didn't?

[Futsuu]

1. 03:15:846 (1) - Why is shorter than Kantan? Do you extend it to 03:20:027 - ? Ahh sorry the Kantan shouldn't extend like this...I've change the Kantan spinner.

[Muzukashii]

1. 00:08:388 (34) - move to 00:08:542 - ? If you follow drm rhythm, sounds better I think. Ah you're right, changed
2. 00:15:685 (63) - change to d? Because of guitar sound pitch. ^
3. 00:23:178 (100) - change to d? Maybe you followed vocal sounds, but I think vocal pitch turn up or turn(?) down 00:23:331 (101) - . I'm not follow the vocal I'm just make a variety on it so it doesn't same as before.
4. 00:28:994 - add d? You can follow a vocal sound. Since this is low dense song part so I don't want put too hard on it
5. 00:34:198 (151) - delete? You can make 3/2 break. Also I can prevent you from putting it on with a pattern 00:33:433 (147,148,149,150) - . It doesn't matter anyway? I feel current pattern flow is kinda great
6. 00:41:851 (184) - change to k? When I consider a vocal sound. Now k kdd k kdd k kdd... repeat is okay... This obvious that I'm following the drum, lol
7. 00:46:735 (204) - change to d? Maybe you consider a guitar sound, but if you changed, more fit I think. Maybe you're right, changed
8. 00:46:888 (205) - change to k? Because of vocal 00:46:123 (201) - As you can see mostly at here I'm following the drum, and the k is kinda strange and soft because at here the song is slowing fading up the dense.
9. 00:55:919 (250) - change to k? Because of vocal too. But the tone of vocal at here is same as next note?
10. 01:12:155 (332) - d? same as 00:23:178 - Same, the tone at here is same as next note.
11. 01:17:968 - add k? same as 00:28:994 - Same as what I've said, at here the song dense is not really high, so I don't want put too hard of pattern to it.
12. 02:22:715 - add k? You can follow a drum sound, also I think is better. Same as above
13. 03:15:693 (923) - change to d? Because of guitar sound pitch. You can hear the part that every middle note I've put as k, that's mean I wanna keep identical to it.

[Oni]

1. 00:14:614 (80) - change to d? If you follow a drum sound, sounds better. But I've think that dkk k k pattern's flow is better, and the drum kick at there is actually not that loud, so I put as k.
2. 00:39:096 (240) - change to d? Because of vocal sound. Same as above, current flow is better
3. 01:23:627 (515) - change to k? same reason. At here I've follow the drum kick which is low-pitch sound.

Without Muzu and BPM, almost fine I think. That's all~

Good luck

mintong89 wrote:

SKSalt wrote:

Hi, Taiko mod request from my queue.

[General]

1. Disable to Widescreen Support. Since the BG is widescreen so I guess it's no need to disable it

osu!wiki wrote:

Wide Screen Support: will remove sidebars/pillarboxes to the left and right side of the playfield, if the client is using any aspect ratio greater than 4:3. This is typically-automatically enabled, when you start using storyboard elements.

1. 01:20:566 (489,490) - dd? ddd k kkd feels much better than two kkd like this.

1. 00:33:433 (146,147,148,149) - ddkk? dkkd dkkd is kinda weird to play and hear.
   
2. I want to touch on the fact that there is a gap between this and Futsuu in a few parts, like 01:37:090 to 02:05:879 which REALLY needs to be changed.
   Not only that, but you need more 'Muzu breaks'. What I mean is, in Oni, it makes sense for 1/1 to be a break since most of the map is 1/4+1/2, but in Muzu where 1/4 is rare and most of the map is 1/2, you need longer and overall more breaks between important parts of the map of at least 2/1. Look at Futsuu, it has a TON of breaks because it follows vocals, so there are a lot of spots with no notes. Muzu is just constant notes.
   All I ask as a soluton is some 2/1 breaks at the end of a phrase/verse/half of the kiai etc. It's the best place to put breaks without making the map ugly.
   
3. 02:44:445 (762,763,764,765,766,767,768,769,770,771,772,773) - d k d k d kkk d d k? The ddd k ddd seems weird since you don't do it much in other parts.

1. HP 6, since new rules. Normally it's higher, but the song is long and not that easy.
2. OD 4. Even though timing is kinda weird, 4 is still very forgiving.
3. A liiiiitle more 1/2 where you see it fits in the last kiai. Muzu has a lot of 1/4 so seeing only 1/1 in Futsuu doesn't work that well.
4. 01:04:950 (169,170,171) - Since it seems like you're mapping vocal, these work a lot better on the 1/2 after, to follow vocals.

1. HP 7 if Futsuu is changed to 6. Same new rules.
2. 00:58:521 (93) - Since this is a "dense" part for Kantan with no breaks, maybe deleting this is the better option.
3. 01:42:613 (167) - Move to 01:42:920 and delete 01:43:226 (168) - ? The rhythm you have doesn't sound good, since drums and the melody are doing something else.
4. 01:53:634 (184,185) - ^ You can also do something like d k k.
5. 01:57:307 (191,192) - ^ It's kinda similar here. I think this one is more obvious.
6. 02:00:981 (198,199) - ^ blah
7. 02:04:042 - Add a note and delete 02:04:348 (204) - ? Same stuff ^
   
8. 02:23:939 (241) - Same as the first suggestion.
9. 02:43:532 (278) - ^

OzzyOzrock wrote:

[Oni]

1. 01:20:566 (489,490) - dd? ddd k kkd feels much better than two kkd like this. yeah

[Muzukashii]

1. 00:33:433 (146,147,148,149) - ddkk? dkkd dkkd is kinda weird to play and hear. fixed
   
2. I want to touch on the fact that there is a gap between this and Futsuu in a few parts, like 01:37:090 to 02:05:879 which REALLY needs to be changed.
   Not only that, but you need more 'Muzu breaks'. What I mean is, in Oni, it makes sense for 1/1 to be a break since most of the map is 1/4+1/2, but in Muzu where 1/4 is rare and most of the map is 1/2, you need longer and overall more breaks between important parts of the map of at least 2/1. Look at Futsuu, it has a TON of breaks because it follows vocals, so there are a lot of spots with no notes. Muzu is just constant notes.
   All I ask as a soluton is some 2/1 breaks at the end of a phrase/verse/half of the kiai etc. It's the best place to put breaks without making the map ugly. It's quite hard to fix honestly but I've try it for that part and kiai
   
3. 02:44:445 (762,763,764,765,766,767,768,769,770,771,772,773) - d k d k d kkk d d k? The ddd k ddd seems weird since you don't do it much in other parts. Change to other pattern

[Futsuu]

1. HP 6, since new rules. Normally it's higher, but the song is long and not that easy.
2. OD 4. Even though timing is kinda weird, 4 is still very forgiving.
3. A liiiiitle more 1/2 where you see it fits in the last kiai. Muzu has a lot of 1/4 so seeing only 1/1 in Futsuu doesn't work that well.
4. 01:04:950 (169,170,171) - Since it seems like you're mapping vocal, these work a lot better on the 1/2 after, to follow vocals.

[Kantan]

1. HP 7 if Futsuu is changed to 6. Same new rules.
2. 00:58:521 (93) - Since this is a "dense" part for Kantan with no breaks, maybe deleting this is the better option.
3. 01:42:613 (167) - Move to 01:42:920 and delete 01:43:226 (168) - ? The rhythm you have doesn't sound good, since drums and the melody are doing something else.
4. 01:53:634 (184,185) - ^ You can also do something like d k k.
5. 01:57:307 (191,192) - ^ It's kinda similar here. I think this one is more obvious.
6. 02:00:981 (198,199) - ^ blah
7. 02:04:042 - Add a note and delete 02:04:348 (204) - ? Same stuff ^
   
8. 02:23:939 (241) - Same as the first suggestion.
9. 02:43:532 (278) - ^

Should be good to go soon

OzzyOzrock wrote:

Looks awesome!

Just one thing popped out:
[Muzukashii]
02:49:032 (746,747,748,749,750,751,752,753,754,755,756,757,758,759,760,761,762,763,764,765,766,767) - The only part that I felt is still really close to Oni. Just remove some extra notes (maybe 02:49:801 (749,752,757) - or something)

no kds! be back