1. Gintoki (5 stars, 330 notes)
2. Kagura (3.46 stars, 116 notes)
3. Sallad's Sadaharu (4.63 stars, 160 notes)
4. Shinpachi (2.43 stars, 102 notes)
5. Taiko (5 stars, 551 notes)

p3n wrote:

[Gintoki]
00:40:823 (2) delete no chance
00:43:647 (2) ^^
00:46:470 (2) ^^
00:49:294 (2) ^^
makes the middle part kinda less repetitive

Distance spacing is incoherent throughout the map (dunno if this is intended for your insane map). It ranges from 0,72 to 0,88 in places (streams) where it seems you wanted it to be 0,8. I'm not here to bitch about 0,01 differences but it is even visible without going into the editor. Example:
01:23:176 (6) prev: 0,87x; next: 0,77x (it sure doesn't look like it is inteded)
tbh the Example is the only one i find needed to be fixed, the rest was done on purpose to make the curves flow better

~star

Samah wrote:

Oh dear I struggled SO hard to find anything to nazi. I actually had to get out the measuring tool in GIMP to check.

[Sallad's Sadaharu]
00:29:750 (2,3,4,5) - Distance between 2-3 and 3-4 are larger than 4-5, although they are the same time gap (1/3 of a beat).
00:41:750 (2) - This would sound better if it started 1/6 of a beat later (on the white tick) but ended at the same place.
00:56:750 (4) - This might look better if you held shift to snap it to the same Y value as the end of slider (3).
01:00:985 (6) - One grid right.
01:15:985 (4,5) - One grid left.

No kudosu plz, not really enough to warrant it I think.

NotShinta wrote:

Gintoki:
00:22:800 - You could add a beat here and make the stacks before and after a stream including said beat. If that makes sense. It suits the drum more, which is what the rest of the combo appears to be mapped to. tbh it mapped to flow with my pattern at 00:15:985 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) -
00:37:514 (2,5) - You could move these down a grid(3) to make these doubles consistent with the sliders. Might be a bit too much though. I dunno. sure, had to move 1,4 as well to keep spacing good
01:27:985 (1,2,3) - I suppose claps could be put onto 3 (and maybe 2) instead of finishes (or maybe even a non-custom finish on 3). Oddly, it's more of an effective end, IMO. i agree that does sound nicer


Kagaru
00:24:808 - Add hitcircle? hmm tbh thats nice

Shinpachi:
00:27:279 (2) - I feel like a silly person saying this, but move 1 grid3 to the right? lolk

Fun, fun, fun, fun.