1. Hard (4,71 stars, 226 notes)
2. Insane (5 stars, 369 notes)
3. Loctav's Taiko Oni (4,83 stars, 650 notes)
4. Normal (3,25 stars, 139 notes)
5. Taiko Muzukashii (4,67 stars, 417 notes)

1. 08/07:
   Uploaded to pending.
   Fixes according to JudgeTheDude's mod.
   Fixes according to ShadowSoul's mod.
   Fixes to the Muzukashii thanks to lepidopodus and MMzz.
2. 08/11:
   Fixes according to Gabe's mod.
3. 08/14:
   Fixes according to Jacob's mod.
4. 08/15:
   Fixes according to Xgor's mod.
5. 08/16:
   Fixes according to Kawayi Rika's mod.
   Fixes according to Scorpiour's mod.
   Fixes according to LKs's mod.
6. 08/17:
   Fixes according to aabc271's mod.
   Bubbled by Sync.
   Self-pop to remove breaks in Hard and Insane.
   Fixes according to Breeze's mod.
7. 08/18:
   Ranked by Sync.

JudgeTheDude wrote:

Voilà le mod que t'as demandé sur #french

[Normal]
00:18:502 (2) - Monte le d'un cran de grid (en grid level 3) Non, il est stacké avec 00:15:393 (2) -
01:31:559 (3) - Place le à x:96 y:232 va pas marcher, ça bousille le spacing et le flow
01:51:378 (3) - Place le à x:384 y:192 hm... ok
01:53:709 (5) - Place le à x:384 y:192 k

[Hard]
00:27:051 (2) - Place le à x:152 y:192 pourquoi ? o.o
00:52:310 (3) - J'aurais bien mis une note là à x:352 y:280 ça va pas avec le pattern... Là je mappe sur la voix

Voilà, et bon boulot. J'ai pu modder que celles là mais c'était vraiment pas mal.

Merci.

ShadowSoul wrote:

Hey Random Mod ~


General
mp3's kb/s: Pass.
Background Resolution: Check.
Previewtime: Check.
Diff Spread: Fine.
Other: Nothing.

[Normal]
00:37:155 (3) - May Place it under the end of the slider like : ew notes hidden under sliders in a Normal. No, the thing here is that (2,3) copy the previous slider, and going back to its end wouldn't play well
01:44:383 (1) - Just put it in the centre
01:46:715 (2) - ^ These would break the spacing
01:51:378 (3) - Replace it to x:416 y: 192
01:53:709 (5) - ^ ? o_O

[Hard]
01:16:404 (1) - Little Spacing Issue oups ><

[Insane]
01:41:080 (6,7) - This Jump would be more Fun 01:40:886 (5,6,7) - form a triangle - I can't really change this jump
01:55:069 (10) - In the same height as (8) ? It's (8) flipped horizontally o.o

thanks

Gabe wrote:

Mod request from Shiro on #modhelp.

Normal

Timing Sections
Certains timings ont été copier/coller de la Insane. Je vais mentionner les timings qui ne sont pas utilisé dans la normal. Il est préférable de les supprimers. Inutile... Au contraire, en fait. Puisque je mappe la Insane d'abord, ces timing sections m'aident à me repérer au niveau du hitsounding par rapport à cette diff.

1. 00:20:008 -
2. 00:20:105 -
3. 00:26:226 -
4. 00:26:323 -
5. 01:27:770 -
6. 01:49:726 -
7. 01:49:921 -
8. 01:50:115 -
9. 01:50:309 -

Circle emplacement

1. 01:41:080 - Il y a un son ici. Tu pourrais mettre un slider à partir de 01:41:080 à 01:41:274 (4) - . Je préfère éviter d'utiliser trop de 1/2 dans une Normal. Honnêtement, je trouve qu'il y en a déjà trop, et le rhythme que j'ai fait convient bien à la situation. =x

Hard
Rien à dire. :< hue 2gud.

Insane

Circle emplacement

1. 01:23:204 (2,6) - Ces deux cercles devrais être aligné sur le même y. Donc, bouge-le à x:72 y:80. mouais... ça casse un peu le spacing mais bon
2. 01:03:968 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - *Commentaire* J'aime ce que t'as fait ici et les deux autres combos. Ce que j'aime pas beaucoup c'est que c'est la même chose mais "scaled". J'aurais aimé voir ce pattern à différente places. Comme exemple, ce combo; 01:10:186 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - . Tu as fait une rotation, donc ça parait pas beaucoup que t'as fait un copier/coller. Le but de ce premier pattern est de montrer justement comment il est fait, pour que les autres soient plus intuitifs à jouer (sinon, le spacing qui augmente aurait paru bizarre). C'est un peu répétitif, mais je trouve que c'est nécessaire.

Muzukashii
Screenshot
J'aime bien la Muzukashii.

Loctav
Screenshot

Hitsounds

1. 00:32:686 - There's alot of don in this section. Maybe you could add a kat there. (k)
2. 01:07:466 (4) - It sounds better in the editor to add a kat here. Since there's three dons. (k)
3. 01:19:125 (4) - Can you delete this kat and replace it by a don? It's almost the same reason as 00:32:686. (d)
4. 01:19:901 - Same as 00:32:686. (k)
5. 01:43:800 (3) - I understand what you did for this part. So it's better to add a kat here because of the sound in the background. (Which the other kats are used for) (k)
6. 01:45:354 - Same as above. (k)
7. 01:50:018 - ^ (k)

Je suis désolé pour ce petit mod. Je suis un peu rouiller mais je risque de revenir si je trouve certains trucs. :<

Shiro wrote:

Merci. C'est déjà mieux que rien. Comme tu peux le voir, les gens ne se bousculent pas pour modder cette map. >.>

Gabe wrote:

Loctav
Screenshot

Hitsounds

1. 00:32:686 - There's alot of don in this section. Maybe you could add a kat there. (k) seems fine.
2. 01:07:466 (4) - It sounds better in the editor to add a kat here. Since there's three dons. (k) okay.
3. 01:19:125 (4) - Can you delete this kat and replace it by a don? It's almost the same reason as 00:32:686. (d) excellent.
4. 01:19:901 - Same as 00:32:686. (k) yup.
5. 01:43:800 (3) - I understand what you did for this part. So it's better to add a kat here because of the sound in the background. (Which the other kats are used for) (k) nice finding.
6. 01:45:354 - Same as above. (k) ^
7. 01:50:018 - ^ (k) ^

1. Please use tick rate 2. It generally should be used for 99% of non 1/3 maps and fits decently well with the song.

1. AR 4, or even 5, makes things feel much less cluttered.
2. 00:42:207 (1,2) - Self explanatory.

1. HP drain 4 for a hard difficulty? This is way too easy; please raise it by one tick.
2. 00:25:108 (1,4) - These two objects slightly overlap, which bothers me because the way you map is usually without any ugly overlapping. It's rather uncharacteristic to have these overlap, no?
3. 00:36:378 (2) - Curve this slider in the opposite direction. It feels odd to have it be the same shape as (1) and would flow better. Here's an example of what I mean;
   SPOILER

   
4. 01:51:766 (6) - There should be a whistle here in order to follow your hitsound pattern.

1. I can't find anything wrong, aaaaah

Jacob wrote:

As you requested via IRC.

[General]

1. Please use tick rate 2. It generally should be used for 99% of non 1/3 maps and fits decently well with the song. I was using tick rate 2 at first, but I realized it gave very weird results in taiko. I know there are two Taiko difficulties, but I still care about the sense my maps make in Taiko (which is why the hitsounding is a barcoding when I could have used claps).

[Normal]

1. AR 4, or even 5, makes things feel much less cluttered. I'm ok with AR4, but AR5 is a bit too much for a Normal. And it's not cluttered. ;_;
2. 00:42:207 (1,2) - Self explanatory.

Aside from these things, I can't find much else. The sliders and patterns are very symmetrical in this difficulty.

[Hard]

1. HP drain 4 for a hard difficulty? This is way too easy; please raise it by one tick. HP drain was 5 before, but the testplays I got whined about it being too high... ;_; raised to 5 again as it was my original intention
2. 00:25:108 (1,4) - These two objects slightly overlap, which bothers me because the way you map is usually without any ugly overlapping. It's rather uncharacteristic to have these overlap, no? aaaa it's a shame D: *wallows in shame*
3. 00:36:378 (2) - Curve this slider in the opposite direction. It feels odd to have it be the same shape as (1) and would flow better. Here's an example of what I mean I know where you come from, but I wanted to highlight the fact that these two sliders are basically the same - prolonging the "bal" then "la" a bit because the notes are slightly held in the song.
4. 01:51:766 (6) - There should be a whistle here in order to follow your hitsound pattern. erf

[Insane]

1. I can't find anything wrong, aaaaah

Wonderful job.

1. 00:56:585 (5,6,7,8,9,10,1) - Ceci pourrait être un autre combo? Autrement dit, mettre un nouveau combo à 00:56:585, par la suite supprimer le NC à 00:57:751 et mettre un combo à 00:57:945. Le vocal recommence à 00:57:945 donc il est inutile de mettre un nouveau combo avant le vocal.

Xgor wrote:

IRC mod

21:25 Xgor: : Well because I didn't find much I'll just make this short IRC mod.
21:25 Shiro: : okay
21:25 Shiro: : remember to post the log
21:26 Xgor: : Really didn't like the short Stack leniency on Insane. Those 1/1 stacks is ugly imo.
21:27 Xgor: : Also I would like to see an Easy on this map
21:27 Xgor: : That's all
21:27 Shiro: : which ones
21:27 Shiro: : can't make an easy
21:27 Shiro: : the Normal's already easy enough x_x
21:28 Xgor: : 01:09:409 (3,4) - 01:15:626 (3,4) - and so on
21:29 Xgor: : Yeah Normal is pretty easy. I think some parts could be trimmed down a bit on it if it's gonna be the easiest
21:29 Xgor: : difficulity but's that's just me
21:29 Shiro: : I can raise it but I hope it doesn't make my other patterns look bad
21:30 Shiro: : Yeah it's fine, I can raise
21:30 Xgor: : It shouldn't really
21:30 Shiro: : what did you think of the Insane particularly
21:30 Shiro: : I mean
21:30 Shiro: : raise the stack leniency
21:31 Xgor: : I like it. They jumps flow very nice. some anti-jumps felt a bit awkward at first but they work nice.
21:31 Shiro: : Which ones
21:32 Xgor: : 00:59:305 (1) - Not really a anti-jump bit felt kinda like it the first time I played it.
21:33 Xgor: : 01:41:663 (8) - This one felt more odd although I dunno what do with it otherwise
21:34 Xgor: : Those was the only ones really
21:34 Shiro: : both are on purpose
21:34 Shiro: : The first one is "regularly spaced" since I saw no reason to have a jump
21:35 Xgor: : Yeah I figured that one.
21:35 Xgor: : *out
21:35 Shiro: : and the second one is meant to feel like a break in the jumps when the instruments go off
21:35 Shiro: : 01:41:663 (8,1,2,3,4) - star pattern
21:35 Shiro: : too
21:35 Xgor: : I do think they work. They just catched me off guard the first time
21:36 Xgor: : I'm a crap player anyways

Kawayi Rika wrote:

Hello ~ Shiro san ~ hi hi

My mod here ~



Red : Must be fixed
Pink : Should be fixed
Purple : Just suggestions

[General]

1. Both taiko diff add AudioLeadIn : 500 , much better with start. agreed

[Insane]

1. 00:56:974 (7,8) - Ctrl+R make more fun imo. hm... I don't see why not

[Hard]

1. AR+1 much better with play. AR7 is a bit high for a Hard imo - especially this kind of difficulty. I find AR7 to just add unnecessary and unfitting difficulty for this. =x

[Normal]

1. Reduce star rating at least 3.24. Star rating doesn't matter. I asked several testplayers and several modders, and they all said that the Normal was easy enough. I'm all for making it a bit easier but I'll need pointers to know what parts to change.
2. HP+1 too low setting for normal diff. okay

That's all ~ Pretty nice map and cool song ~


Call me back recheck ~ when you are ready ~

1. 00:20:057 - you may miss a note here~
2. 00:37:446 - unnecessary inherited point
3. 00:50:756 (1,2) - a slider here may be better for the vocal~~~
4. 00:54:448 (3) - stack to next slider's head?
5. 01:09:409 (2,3) -
   1. (2) - 424:184
   2. (3) - 296:168
   try this placement? i suppose it can follow the music better :>
6. 01:52:349 (2) - (nazi)looked not very nice.. maybe u can reduce the curve?

1. 00:16:948 (7) - i'd like to reduce the volumn of normal sample~~~it's too sudden now
2. 00:42:012 - add a note here to follow the vocal ?
3. 00:55:419 - ^
4. 00:56:196 - ^
5. 01:14:072 (2,3,4) - maybe u can make it more smooth like
   
   SPOILER

   
6. 01:16:987 - add a note?
7. 01:18:541 - ^
8. 01:20:095 - ^
9. 01:28:839 - why break here....?
10. 01:39:720 (1,2,3,4,5) - i should say...i don't like this kinda linear pattern....
11. 01:47:297 - may miss a note ~
12. 01:52:155 (1,2) - consider changing (1) to a 1/2 slider, and move (2) to next red tick ?
    

1. 00:32:880 (1,2) - make a slider for some change in beat feeling ?
2. 00:33:269 (3,4) - ^.... too many 1/2 notes continuing...
3. 01:09:409 (3) - try a ctrl+h?
4. 01:28:645 - unnecessary break imo~
5. 01:33:891 (3) - rotate 180 but keep the origin by selection centre?
   
6. 01:34:668 (5) - ^
7. 01:36:611 (2) - try ctrl+r for better flow?

Scorpiour wrote:

Hi there~~ mod for request~
sorry for my late >.< hi~ it's fine

[Normal]

1. 00:20:057 - you may miss a note here~ No, I was focusing on the vocals in the beginning, so that clap thing in the background was missed on purpose.
2. 00:50:756 (1,2) - a slider here may be better for the vocal~~~ I made a slight jump at this point, because both notes are highlighted in the song. Adding a slider instead of two circles would kill the jump and the second beat of the slider, which doesn't need to be clicked, wouldn't be highlighted.
3. 00:54:448 (3) - stack to next slider's head? I don't think there should be any stack in a Normal diff - they're quite hard to play.
4. 01:09:409 (2,3) -
   1. (2) - 424:184
   2. (3) - 296:168
   what
   try this placement? i suppose it can follow the music better :>
5. 01:52:349 (2) - (nazi)looked not very nice.. maybe u can reduce the curve? Made a better curve

[Hard]

1. 00:16:948 (7) - i'd like to reduce the volumn of normal sample~~~it's too sudden now The hitsounds are the same as Insane... and the volume was already reduced in the sample
2. 00:42:012 - add a note here to follow the vocal ?
3. 00:55:419 - ^
4. 00:56:196 - ^
   I can't do that, because I followed the vocals by simplifying the rhythms a bit, in order not to have the same timeline as Insane
5. 01:14:072 (2,3,4) - maybe u can make it more smooth like
   I wanted this to be sharp, because it's the first point in the pattern where there are 4 1/2 notes (even though there's a slider), so I wanted it to contrast with the rest of the patterns =x
6. 01:16:987 - add a note?
7. 01:18:541 - ^
8. 01:20:095 - ^
   same asa bove
9. 01:28:839 - why break here....? I'm kind of afraid the drain would be too high here, so I added that break to make sure people don't fail to drain at this point ><
10. 01:39:720 (1,2,3,4,5) - i should say...i don't like this kinda linear pattern.... made something less linear
11. 01:47:297 - may miss a note ~ I understand why you think I did, but I wanted to keep the symmetry in the pattern, and adding a 1/2 here would kill the emphasis on 01:48:075 (7) - ><
12. 01:52:155 (1,2) - consider changing (1) to a 1/2 slider, and move (2) to next red tick ? 01:51:766 (6,1,2,3,4) - Is a butterfly pattern, which is why I went for the full 1/1 ><

[Insane]

1. 00:32:880 (1,2) - make a slider for some change in beat feeling ? ooooh you're right
2. 00:33:269 (3,4) - ^.... too many 1/2 notes continuing... no, these are purposely 1/2
3. 01:09:409 (3) - try a ctrl+h? That would break the flow with a sharp turn, and kill the consistency (I'm following the same kind of movement as the patterns before)
4. 01:28:645 - unnecessary break imo~ same as Hard =x I don't want the drain to kill people here
5. 01:33:891 (3) - rotate 180 but keep the origin by selection centre?
6. 01:34:668 (5) - ^
   That would break the spacing (because these are normally spaced) and the pattern =x
7. 01:36:611 (2) - try ctrl+r for better flow? ooo that's indeed better

that's all~~hopes it can help u ~~ good luck with rank :>