1. ColdTooth's Hard (2.88 stars, 358 notes)
2. Insane (3.48 stars, 537 notes)
3. Normal (1.92 stars, 256 notes)

ColdTooth wrote:

Lol what?





Did they change the star rating now?

KerryShenSA wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

Lol what?





Did they change the star rating now?

I'm having that problem on like almost all maps

1. Nothing? There's a space before the colon in Source, also you can tag it with "mlp"

1. 00:03:894 (1) - some kind of (quiet?) finish hitsound would be nice
2. 00:05:225 (5) - stack better
3. 00:09:096 (5) - ^ (seems it's done on purpose, so I'll stop mentioning)
4. 00:10:427 (6) - I'd move it 1/2nd forward and add a note at 00:10:427, because downbeat is still a thing to follow, or start sliders at. You'll need to re-do 00:11:153 (8) though
5. 00:11:636 (1) - aw you missed finish (check the rest of them by yourself)
6. 00:14:782 (8) - why? I would rotate it like this, because it looks better and also plays a bit better: http://puu.sh/9s5Ps/5b0ada6d13.jpg
7. 00:30:991 (7) - I'd rather not use pattern comboing, because it does not always follow the song
8. 00:34:862 (2) - same as above (okay, I think that you're able to find and fix them if you're going to fix this)
9. 00:40:911 (6,7,8) - please space them out to make player move more freely here. It also irks me that I have to constantly return back to the center of each slider in order to start dragging the next one, and a bigger spacing could probably cure this
10. 00:48:653 (1,2,3) - same as above. I would also start them from white ticks, well you know why
11. 01:09:701 (1,2) - perhaps you should re-work this and also map that sound at 01:10:064, which is very noticeable and is calling to follow self. A 3/4th slider would work, probably
12. 01:21:798 (3,7) - you can add whistles from default drum sampleset here
13. 01:27:362 (2,3) - red ticks issues. Well, the sound at 01:27:604 is stronger than 01:27:362, that's why I keep mentioning it
14. 01:35:104 (1,2,3) - you could shape them like this: http://puu.sh/9s70a/6f621b7a22.jpg plays better, in my opinion
15. 01:58:088 (4,5,6) - looks actually worse than in editor because of auto stacking: http://puu.sh/9s7hJ/6e4c5a9b9b.jpg perhaps you should move these notes somewhere else or make the slider less curvy
16. 02:52:523 (7,8,9) - I don't really like how it looks together with these notes. You better change them a little, so they can become the one shape http://puu.sh/9s7Gh/21e8a37dc3.jpg, or make something similar to 02:50:588 (2,3,4)
17. 02:54:217 (1) - but there is no sound to spin to! I would replace it with a single note

1. 00:06:314 (3,4) - space them out for a better visual experience: http://puu.sh/9s81L/6c5b1f291d.jpg
2. 00:11:636 (1) - you shouldn't skip hitsounds when the music itself gives them to you. Add a finish here! Oh, and check the rest of your map for moments like this one, for example, 00:17:443 (1,2,3)
3. 00:18:411 (3) - start it 1/4th earlier, because this is where that sound appears in the music
4. 00:23:975 (4) - this slider looks like it needs help or something. You could come up with some more beautiful shape, such as http://puu.sh/9s8uC/1ca5f24036.jpg (you'll need to rotate it a bit)
5. 00:40:427 (5) - it'd be cool if you turned this into a slider? Or a short 1/4th repeating slider, considering the beats on the background
6. 02:46:475 (1) - you should move it up and right for a better "flow": http://puu.sh/9s8Vp/6f51efc9a5.jpg

1. 00:52:765 (2) - I don't really feel why; probably because of these 1/4th notes right before it
2. 01:31:717 (2) - because the slider before lasts longer than vocals, and the player may want to hit the note earlier, you know, as if he was trying to catch the sound at 01:31:354

1. 00:07:282 (6,1) - looks like a jump, please fix
2. 00:09:217 (4,1) - ^ same. Reduce the spacing
3. 00:09:701 (1,1) - saaaaame (okay not mentioning anymore)
4. 00:15:991 (1,2,3) - space them out, there's no more room after you increased CS
5. 00:18:411 (1) - seems too short to me. Perhaps a long slider would work better
6. 00:36:798 (1,2) - space them out (basically, just skim through the whole difficulty and you see such things yourself
7. 00:40:669 (1) - everything around this slider has a curve, but the slider itself doesn't. Mind fixing?
8. 00:45:991 (3,1) - you should rotate the repeating slider somehow, because it's not really comfortable to move to the opposite direction after you pass it. Same with 02:34:378 (3)
9. 01:21:314 (1,2) - add drum whistles to the end of these?
10. 01:31:959 (1,2,3,4,5) - I'd replace first 4 with two short 1/2nd slider because I don't enjoy multiple stacks in a row
11. 02:02:201 (1,2,3,4) - may be difficult to follow (considering that it starts on red offbeat ticks)
12. 02:11:636 (1) - just so you remember that every slider before that looked like this had only one repeat and not two. Can cause a combo break
13. 02:54:217 (1) - I would replace it with a single note for the same reason as on Insane

Kitokofox wrote:

ColdTooth's Hard

00:08:975 (3,4,5,1) - There's a couple of groups like this around the beginning. They don't feel tied to the song at all and more thrown together.
00:16:475 (3,4,1) - In relation to above statement I really loved this.
00:40:911 (2) - I thought of this being 1/4s or a short reverse slider when I saw it. Slider is ok too though i guess
01:05:104 (2,1) - I didn't exactly enjoy how this was positioned, it felt inconsistent to the rest of the map. I tried to change the first slider into circles. I'm not saying this is a serious thing but it looks odd.
01:38:975 (2) - In a Hard, I bet you could follow the rhythm more with this slider
02:46:475 (1) - Didn't expect that note to be a little further than normal. It could make people think that it's a 1/2 step and end the slider early.

Insane

In quite a few cases I had myself guessing at the timing of notes. The spacing was very variant and kind of confusing.
Maybe it would be nice to make a few more different patterns. It feels like you copy pasted a select set of patterns and used them over and over again.
00:40:911 (6) - Like the Hard, I think you can do especially more with this in an Insane.

This song sounds awesome, and the maps are great so far, I wish you best of luck ColdTooth and ztrot