1. Easy (1.24 stars, 81 notes)
2. Fuuko's Star (2.34 stars, 111 notes)
3. Normal (2.36 stars, 107 notes)
4. Sweet (0.38 stars, 19 notes)

arken1015 wrote:

[Easy]
00:32:12(4) - [Suggestion] How about move 1 grid left?

[Normal]
01:15:91(5) - [Suggestion] How about move 1 grid left and down to make curve pattern (3,4,5,6,7,8,1)?

Not much issues as I saw.
Good luck.

Here's my star.
And don't give kudosu for this reply :3...

Crimson_SoulZ wrote:

this is my first time on modding so i dont know if this is good or not


Normal

00:44:071 (6) - new combo
00:51:031 (5) - new combo
01:27:091 (6) - new combo
01:34:051 (5) - new combo

Easy

00:51:092 (3) - could use a new combo
01:35:012 (5) - could use a new combo


have a star since this is good

Derekku Chan wrote:

[General]
*Move to Pending
*Harder difficulties please. I do not want to add a harder diff for this song.
*This song is in 3/4, not 4/4. Change ALL timing sections to reflect this. Done.
*More tags could be added if you want like "Vocaloid" Done.
*Source is lasdkjf not sure. One website said enameru-P, but I think he's just the person that made a 3D PV for the song. I'll keep looking in a bit to see if I can find anything. Done, also added enameru-P as a tag. I also do not know who the source is.

[Easy]
00:26:072 (1,2) - Sounds awkward. Add a circle where 2 starts and then start that slider a white tick later. Done.
01:06:032 (1) - Extending one white tick would sound better. Done.
01:49:051 (1) - Ends at an awkward spot. Extend to the white tick and silence the whole spinner with a 0 volume soft section. Done.

[Normal]
*Raise overall diff and drain Done.
*Perhaps smaller circles? I like large circles.
01:06:031 (1) - Extending one white tick would sound better. Done.
01:49:051 (1) - Ends at an awkward spot. Extend to the white tick and silence the whole spinner with a 0 volume soft section. Done.

EDIT: Whoops, I meant "Move to WIP/Help" Done.

Source: lasdkjf

blissfulyoshi wrote:

]I do not want to add a harder diff for this song.

Derekku Chan wrote:

Source: lasdkjf

Noooooo that was just me key smashing XD T_T I have been interpreting things way too literally.

blissfulyoshi wrote:

]I do not want to add a harder diff for this song.

I don't know if it can be ranked in its current state then. Sure, songs would be ranked with only 1-2 diffs when osu! started, but nowadays there are higher standards. If you don't want to MAKE a harder diff, then type that in your OP and maybe someone can make one. It is true that it is very rare for a song to have only 2 diffs these days, but the rules state you must have more than 1 diff not 2. Also, I don't feel a hard diff was very appropriate for the song since it is supposed to be nice and peaceful. As a result, I want to rank this song with the current 2 diffs.

EDIT: Also, it might not be a bad idea to add the 3D PV as a video for this, but that's completely up to you. Done.

Derekku Chan wrote:

blissfulyoshi wrote:

]I do not want to add a harder diff for this song.

I don't know if it can be ranked in its current state then. Sure, songs would be ranked with only 1-2 diffs when osu! started, but nowadays there are higher standards. If you don't want to MAKE a harder diff, then type that in your OP and maybe someone can make one.

Dusty wrote:

[General]
Select all the sliders that are supposed to be straight lines and make their slider curve type Linear.

[Normal]
Slider nazi!
00:28:051 (3)
00:32:011 (3,1) - I like the end of one slider to "point towards" the next slider (math way: tangent line at the endpoint intersects next note)
00:35:071 (3) - Lopsided on the left
00:44:071 (1) - I like the red sliderpoint to be inside the slidertick (make it longer but shorter)
00:59:011 (5) - Strange-looking.
01:42:031 (5) - Slider Curve Type: Linear? It might take a lot of time to make it look good if you do it that way though. I think this is a good way to do that
I tried to fix everything. Hopefully, you like the results.

Derekku Chan wrote:

I don't know if it can be ranked in its current state then. Sure, songs would be ranked with only 1-2 diffs when osu! started, but nowadays there are higher standards. If you don't want to MAKE a harder diff, then type that in your OP and maybe someone can make one.

Well, if it needs three...
Thank you, added your diff and hitsounds.
If you may, I have one suggestion. Please remove all of the slider whistles since they don't fit the song.

*star + diff

Dusty wrote:

Well, if it needs three...

Derekku Chan wrote:

Dusty wrote:

Well, if it needs three...

I actually meant a harder diff, not "more than two" in general. After talking to a couple of people, it seems like a harder diff isn't required, but I guess we'll see.

PS: You can move this back to Pending if you think it's okay, I suppose.

Shinde wrote:

Minor timeline problem on Normal.

Normal
00:44:071 (1) - Extend 1/4 Fixed.
00:46:051 (3) - ^ ^
Maybe turn Kiai off after the Star slider is done? Don't feel strongly about this either way, both would be fine. I was planning to do this but forgot, thanks for reminding me.

I don't know what the 3DPV looks like, but if you include a video, a falling snow SB isn't really necessary, and a star2 would suffice nicely. Star 2 is coming.

All the technical stuff seems to check out. You turned hitcircle size down one on Dusty's right? I think it'll look much better.

I think that's it. Star.

blissfulyoshi wrote:

Thanks for doing research and replying.

blissfulyoshi wrote:

If people really want a harder diff, I guess I will map one, but in my belief, a hard opinion ruins the mood set by the song.