1. CDFA's Normal (4.01 stars, 201 notes)
2. Easy (1.57 stars, 163 notes)
3. Hard (4.58 stars, 332 notes)
4. ignore's Taiko (4.94 stars, 848 notes)
5. Kana's CTB (5 stars, 642 notes)
6. Lost (5 stars, 659 notes)

lepidopodus wrote:

I asked several players and they think ignore's Taiko is best cause it's the easiest one. Yeah, seems players like easy map and others are quite hard.

MMzz wrote:

/me had an idea after reading all of lepido's and Zeki-don's post.
Solution = Just don't add a taiko since this song is obviously to retarded to map. (It's a good song just in mapping sense it's terrible)

MMzz wrote:

DJPop wrote:

Isn't "Lost" alone too difficult to play in Taiko? :<
I think Zekira's Taiko would satisfy most skilled Taiko players since Lost's last part is a machine gun lol

yeah but there is nothing we can do about the lost diff since it's osu!, it will get played on Taiko anyways.
No need for 2 crazy things for taiko. >_>

matthewhln wrote:

To conclue,
There might be really need a taiko difficult for this since Lost is too hard for taiko
I will suggest [Ignore's taiko] among them

wmfchris wrote:

Conclusion: ign's taiko : >

Darksoul wrote:

i choose siupain's ctb (Kana's CTB)
the beginning of pieguy's is good ,but after beginning,there r too many hyperdash,i dont think is necessary
and yoki's ctb...hmm i dont think its a map,that;s all
and crow'ctb.i think it;s good but some part should hard but he did easyD: and some part should easy but have many jump D:

arien666 wrote:

[crowzen2] Rate = 8.2 / 10
(aru's CtB difficulty line) 86+3/100+20(89/120) :3(Violet)
Good patterns, but some droplets are like ;_;

[KanaRin] Rate = 7.9 / 10
(aru's CtB difficulty line) 93+8/100+20(101/120) :3(Silver)
Some quick dash are hard imo ;_;

[pieguy1372] Rate = 8.4 / 10
(aru's CtB difficulty line) 78+1/100+20(79/120) :3(mid-Violet)
Enough easy and Enough hard :3

[yokijudai] Rate = 7.9 / 10
(aru's CtB difficulty line) 59+0/100+20(59/120) :3(Red)
So so :3

Another judging but...
I'm not good at CtB ;_;

joynama wrote:

siupain's CTB (Kana's CTB) is nice~

-maJu wrote:

My opinion is that kana's CtB is the best... :3

ZHSteven wrote:

crow's ctb:i think this diff cannot catch the whole song..like darksoul says..when i think the place will be hard, it is easy...but the seems easy part contains losts of red fruit= =
kana's ctb:the whole diff is great~XD but only one problem..i don't like the way using red fruit..it makes it almost like tag map. it is not good for a normal map contains the jump like tag map~~XD
pieguy's ctb:wow~it contains a lot of traingle fruit which i cannot do well....i like the way using these traingles~but maybe... it can be more jumper(only my suggest~)
yoki's ctb:well.... i don't know how to say but..these exteme jumps like flyaway will be human killer...i guess even a very skilful player cannot do it well...
so i think pieguy's maybe the best~

TheVileOne wrote:

Personally I think all the CTB diffs are completely unplayable with those custom beats. You shouldn't be able to see through the beats. It makes the notes blend so much with the background, it's ridiculous to play.

corno wrote:

I'm not really good at criticizing, but the best CtB difficulty so far is pieguy's.
For Kana's: I think inclining the sliders that start at 02:03:030 would be good, your difficulty is my favorite.

[JPSNS]Shana wrote:

hmm.. i'm not maper , but I think
[CTB diff]
Kanarin Diff is best..
like slider , Hehe

[Beatrice] wrote:

kana's CTB is very good!!! (x4)

hitmantutor wrote:

Kana's CTB = 8/10
great, i think kana is good at making ctb diffs lol
ctb gods will be satisfied by this ._.

pieguy's CTB = 8.5/10
this diff suits me the best, idk why lol

yoki's CTB = 6.5/10
sorry but in my opinion as a ctb player, slow bpm with little beats to catch is annoying -_-"

singma wrote:

i think kana's CTB is the best

Garven wrote:

[Normal]
01:37:030 (1) - Maybe lower this a little to get rid of overlap?
Fixed.

[Hard]
01:48:530 (4) - Maybe scoot this left a little bit to smooth out the curve?
Fixed.
01:50:530 (4) - Same, but right?
Fixed.

Natteke desu wrote:

Wait, I expected it to be harder.
WHERE IS MY STREAM MADNESS? ;_:
Score is too high D:

Krisom wrote:

[General]
/me looks at hard and normal... ...are you going to map something in between? The star rating gap is kinda high o_o.
Don't trust star levels ._.
Look carefully at the spinner meter animation, I think something is off...
Nothing wrongs :/
N-No breaks?
Yeah lol

[Normal] <- THIS IS EASY <.<"!
Easy+ , so it can be called Normal.
God, there are a lot of distance snap breaks for the easiest difficulty, even in the name of symmetry, if this is the easiest diff, spacing shouldn't break (A few examples below + the normal mod).
Spacings are fine if they're clear and able to read.
00:39:030 (1) - Example
Fixed.
00:59:030 (1) - Example
X
01:06:530 (4) - shouln't this be an horizontal flip of 01:04:530 (2) to follow the same pattern?
Fixed.
01:26:030 (4) - Example
X
01:28:030 (2) - Example
X
01:30:030 (4) - Example
X
01:41:030 (1) - Avoid using whistle+finish in the same note.
X
01:41:780 (3) - ^
X
02:07:030 (1) - THE best example (Hey, 02:03:030 up to 02:10:530 is not that fun to play anyways imo)
Fixed.
02:19:030 (1) - Example (Maybe rotating (1,2,3,4) by -45 would help, then rotate the next combo 02:23:030 (1,2,3,4) by 45)
Fixed.
02:27:030 (1,2,3,4....,1,2,3,4) - Finish abuse o_o
Listen to the song.
02:47:030 (1) - Example
X

[Hard]
00:37:030 (1,2...8) - Pull the whole combo up a bit?
Fixed.
00:40:530 (7,8) - Put them closer to the Y axis, and the copy, paste in the following combo, reverse selection and make some hitsound changes to fix the spacing between (8) and (1)
Fixed.
00:40:780 (8) - Avoid using Clap+Finish in the same note. Finish doesn't being here imo.
Listen carefully.
00:41:780 (4) - ^
^
01:11:030 (1) - Why don't you alling it with (7)? I mean, everything else is alligned before.
Fixed.
01:47:030 (1,2,3,4,5) - What about this? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/15822 (apply to the next combo too if you do)
Fixed.
01:55:030 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - What about this? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/15825 & http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/15826
Fixed.
02:00:030 (4) - Remove the clap at the end.
X
02:01:530 (3) - Why is this clapped? If anything, a finish would suit it at the end.
I'd like to add it.
02:08:530 (4) - Remove the finish+clap at the end. If you want a finish, add one at 02:09:030 (1)'s start
X
02:16:780 (8) - Remove the finish+clap. 02:17:030 (1)'s finish is enough
X
02:18:280 (6) - Remove the finish+clap
X
So much finsih abuse o_o"! If you're gonna finish abuse, at least tune down the hitsounds volume a bit.
Fixed.

EDIT2: Inb4 DJPop's 200th map is "Hatsune miku Stole the Precious thing" or "Miku's Perfect Math Class"
Depends on what is in Nico Nico Douga that time =P

TKiller wrote:

[Lost]
00:37:030 (1) - are completely hidden sliders rankable? Fine with me, actually, but..
Fixed.
00:59:280 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - this is highly uncreative, even boring, just TOO MUCH copypaste, it's fine when it's about 4-6, maybe 8 times, but 14 times... I highly suggest you remapping all of these before 01:09:280 to music, rather than to UN! U-UN!, than it'll be much more reasonable
Fixed.
01:44:592 (1) - eh, people are expecting this map to have hellish lot of streams (me included) you could make a stream here synced to her scream, just a suggestion
A bit hard to guess what to follow.
02:33:030 (1) - maybe a new pattern here as new vocal appears? That clicking to UN UN UN UN UN UN UN UN gets a bit boring after a while
Fixed.

samiljul wrote:

May I make Taiko diff?
Sorry, I'm planning to map Taiko soon.