1. Forever! (4.95 stars, 473 notes)
2. Jar's Young! (3.25 stars, 274 notes)
3. jericho's Easy (0.83 stars, 145 notes)
4. Roko-Don's Taiko (5 stars, 888 notes)

Derekku wrote:

[General]
*Defaut numbers are for the hitcircles, not score. Thus, you should delete the x, dot, comma, and percent elements. Done.
*You need an approachcircle (even if it's the default). Can do <3
*Why is there another .osb in the SB folder? opps....
*Why does the "map by" storyboard element appear in BOTH breaks? The first break is fine, but having it a second time just looks really strange.Fixed
*The ending of both maps were a bit awkward. Another rainbow strobe and a singly kiai fountain at 03:17:748 would look very nice. placing fountains like that makes peppy grumpy as to if it's rankable or not meh I avoid it.
*Why is Jericho2442 in the tags? Storyboard/Skin contributors never get added to tags. o-o; Why not?
*Epilepsy warning definitely needs to be added to both difficulties.strobes aren't that fast it's not 4 or more strobes a sec.
*Those dark blue strobes are really strong. http://puu.sh/huM Could you lighten them a little bit? o-o; For example, it looks like the blue strobes get stronger and stronger starting at 01:10:689, but the last strobe before the break is really bright.
*Offset is a bit early. I was 5-10ms late when playing, but a +5 should be enough. Offset is fine.

[Jar's Young]
*Very nice, for a normal-ish difficulty. I can not accept this as the easiest difficulty in the mapset. The large distance spacing between 1/2 beats, 1/1 jumps, high difficulty settings, constant off-beats, etc. are way too difficult.
*Even for a normal diff, though, the difficulty settings are a bit too high. Please lower the approach rate a tick, the OD 1-2 ticks, and the Drain about 2 ticks.That's Jarby's call

[Forever]
00:50:174 - expected a note here D: Yeah I didn't add it there because it starts to fell like a massive 1/2 steam plus it would fuck up my patterns.
00:53:703 - ^ (and in the other spots where you didn't map to the lyrics of "i wanna be forever young"
01:14:218 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - nice anti-jumps :p
01:28:115 (3,4) - Unrankable. It's too confusing to tell which is the slider and which is the note with snaking sliders turned off. Fixed but I could argue you that one the OD is really high even without snaking you should be able to tell.http://puu.sh/huA
01:42:233 (5,1) - Here's it's fine since the new combo tells it all.
02:28:336 - Having this section of the map use a slower slider speed (like Jar did) would fit much better imo. I can't stress this enough I very VERY rarely change slider speed.
*A big difficulty jump from Jar's diff.that is is

This mapset needs an easier difficulty. I'd also like to see a Hard-ish one in-between the current "Normal" and "Insane" so that more players can enjoy this mapset. If you don't want to make a Hard, at least lower the difficulty settings on Forever a little bit.

ztrot wrote:

Derekku wrote:

*Epilepsy warning definitely needs to be added to both difficulties.

strobes aren't that fast it's not 4 or more strobes a sec.