forum

Billy Joel - Uptown Girl [with hard]

posted
Total Posts
23
Topic Starter
Jay_old
LuigiHann
I like this one a lot. The timing is perfect, and I like that it's easy. One suggestion is that the placement of the notes on the screen could be a bit more varied. I also hope that when more features are added for storyboarding the background images, you'll consider putting some kind of Ouendan-like comic in the background... this song seems perfect for a fun little story.
Topic Starter
Jay_old

Jay wrote:

http://peppy.chigau.com/files/Billy%20Joel%20-%20Uptown%20Girl.osz
I was going to do that :)
As for the variety, some will be cut for the story, so it'll work.
Extor
First, very nice beatmap!

Next, critics:

I think the BPM should be 129.09. Resnap all the notes with 1/4 after setting it.

At 2:02 you should keep the spacing you did with the rest of the song, because it's the same combo color and placement but the times are different.

And the last note should be a 1/2 beat ahead of time.

Next time, try to use a bit more sliders or some other patterns in the beatmap, I like it anyways, but a bit more variety is welcomed.
Topic Starter
Jay_old

Extor wrote:

First, very nice beatmap!

Next, critics:

I think the BPM should be 129.09. Resnap all the notes with 1/4 after setting it.

At 2:02 you should keep the spacing you did with the rest of the song, because it's the same combo color and placement but the times are different.

And the last note should be a 1/2 beat ahead of time.

Next time, try to use a bit more sliders or some other patterns in the beatmap, I like it anyways, but a bit more variety is welcomed.
I'll do that. I didn't use sliders to keep it simple though, I'm using them a lot more in my second song (Bohemian Rhapsody).

EDIT:http://peppy.chigau.com/files/Billy Joel - Uptown Girl.osz
Better?
Hitoshirenu Shourai
Not bad. The timing is still a bit off, and I have a problem with the offset. Other than that, it seems pretty decent.
Topic Starter
Jay_old
http://peppy.chigau.com/files/Billy Joel - Uptown Girl.osz
Fixed it again following what you said. I had a hard time with the offset. And I changed some beats on it.
RemmyX25

Jay wrote:

http://peppy.chigau.com/files/Billy%20Joel%20-%20Uptown%20Girl.osz
There ya go. The download wont work if there's spaces
Topic Starter
Jay_old

RemmyX25 wrote:

Jay wrote:

http://peppy.chigau.com/files/Billy%20Joel%20-%20Uptown%20Girl.osz
There ya go. The download wont work if there's spaces
Sorry for that :X
Extor
I was replaying it in the editor and found out that it has lots of timing changes. =O

One is at 00:38:90, other at 53 seconds and probably at others... :/
RemmyX25

Jay wrote:

RemmyX25 wrote:

Jay wrote:

http://peppy.chigau.com/files/Billy%20Joel%20-%20Uptown%20Girl.osz
There ya go. The download wont work if there's spaces
Sorry for that :X
Dont sweat it. i made the same mistake on my first beatmap too! ^_^
Hitoshirenu Shourai
The timing is still a bit off, but that's due to tempo changes mainly. Keep it up, this is looking better every time I see it! =D
Topic Starter
Jay_old

hitoshirenu wrote:

The timing is still a bit off, but that's due to tempo changes mainly. Keep it up, this is looking better every time I see it! =D
I changed some more. If you still have something could you be specific to the problem? I'd really love that. If you want you can change it the beatmap at your liking :).
Extor
Oh, this new version is almost perfect. I changed a bit the BPM and offset and I think it's way better this way. Try it and upload it to the .osz if you find it good.

Cya!

Download: Billy Joel - Uptown Girl (Jay) [Easy].osu
Topic Starter
Jay_old
http://peppy.chigau.com/files/Billy%20Joel%20-%20Uptown%20Girl.osz

Resnapped some missnapped notes, kept the new BPM and Offset.`:)
SuperDevil
The URL isn't working. Please fix. :)
Extor
Fixed the link, and adding to the rankings.
Nintendonick4
A very well-timed map. The beat placement is simplistic, but I think it goes with the song... Easy and slow-paced; besides, a downtown boy doesn't worry about fancy note placements.
Topic Starter
Jay_old
http://peppy.chigau.com/files/Billy Joel - Uptown Girl (Jay) [Hard].osu

Now with hard.
LuigiHann
Can somebody, uh... fix hard?
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply