lovhin456 wrote:

Hi! Yay KHR! >w<

Song's Info;
- Tags; Add Akira Amano ok

General;
- Offset is not the same on every diff. Hard is different o crap
- Try these colors ? okay

Combo1 : 232,111,21
Combo2 : 210,49,49
Combo3 : 153,123,83
Combo4 : 207,184,48
Combo5 : 80,134,163

Skin;
- Maybe try this cursor instead ? I made myself, is pink but you could change the color or ask me to change it for you i prefer Mok's one
[attachment=0:b07ef]cursor.png[/attachment:b07ef]

Easy;
- 00:45:188 >> Sounds better without the whistle imo yeah okay
- 00:55:777 >> Whistle to slider's body ? nah
- 01:03:131 (2,3,4) >> Add a note here, delete (3) and remove whistle from (4) nah

Hard;
- 00:02:535 >> End the spinner here ? Feels better to me, also gives more time for players to prepare completely ruins the effect then
- 00:04:594 >> ^ ^
- 00:45:186 >> Remove whistle ? noo
- 00:50:922 >> A note sounds really good here yeah okay
- 00:55:775 >> Whistle to slider's body no
- 00:59:893 >> Remove the whistle from the slider's body noo
- 01:15:189 >> Remove whistle and clap, add finish ? nooo
- 01:31:661 >> Add whistle use to be whistle there, but i think it sounds better without

Insane;
- 00:02:537 >> End the spinner here ? no~
- 00:04:596 >> ^ ~
- 00:41:805 >> Whistle ? nah
- 00:42:099 >> ^ ~
- 00:42:393 >> ^ ~
- 01:15:485 >> Add clap ? noo
- 01:31:663 >> Whistle ? ~

* Really nice! Star + Kd Star ~

HeatKai wrote:

[General]

Mp3 Bitrate : 192kbps ( good )

Video ( frame size ) : No video (okay )

Skin : star2.png ( make it lighter ? ) other's fine.

Background : the SB BG (1024x640) ? change it to (800x600) i dunno, cause the quality will change...... i'll actually have to ask about this

Kiai time : all same , ( good )

Snapping : none ( good )

Preview Point : all same , but maybe put at the starting of kiai part is better ? No. ^.^

Diffs : 1 easy , 1 hard , 1 insane . I recommend you to map a [normal] diff ;P my Hard was supposed to be Normal, but it turned out harder than expected. it's really (i think) a Normal+ that MB wanted to call Hard :/

Audio Lead-in : all 3000 ( okay )

Artist : Toshihiko Sahashi (good )

Title : Tsuna awakens ( good )

source : Katekyo Hitman REBORN! ( good ) :3

Tags : all the same ( okay )



[easy]
Why SV so high @_@ all diffs. are harder-than-average, so that the diff. spread is more even. either way, i think it's fine ._.

01:08:719 (2,3,4,5,6) - remove whistle um no

[hard]
00:02:831 (1) - can't you just start the spinner here -_- ? cause not
00:04:890 (1) - so near with the end of the spinner @_@ end your spinner here better ? no. why don't people get it :/
00:36:952 (3,4) - i think here use 1/2 repeat slider is better @_@ noo D:
01:18:132 (1,2) - ^ ^

[insane]
00:02:831 (1) - can't you just start the spinner here -_- ? -.-
00:23:862 (1) - delete ? WHAT NO
00:55:924 (4) - ^ NO EVEN MORE
01:26:074 (4) - new combo no need
01:26:662 (7) - new combo ~
01:27:251 (10) - new combo ^

Epic jump @_@
slider so fast @_@

[overall]
Cool sb :3

Star already
Good luck YGOkid8 !~

qinche wrote:

random mod comes...

[general]

- the warning actually kinda covers the first note, i dunno if this is a big issue but i missed reading the note in insane at first glance. need to ask some BATs about this
- is 0% hitsound appropriate/rankable in insane? since the system forced editing to not use anything under 5%, im not sure about this anymore... it should be fine since it's just silencing the spinner...
- countdown is useless since u added 3s lead-in, might just disable it okay

[insane]
00:33:275 (3) - finish? nah
00:42:540 (5,6) - add clap, sounds better i disagree
00:42:835 (7) - this imo better not stack with the previous one becuz it stops the flow, the whole pattern flows but suddenly stops here, kinda not what i have expected. on the contrary, it actually flows better like that
00:55:630 (2) - and so is this one. even weirder not stacked
01:15:632 (7) - finish? nah
01:24:898 (5,6) - add clap nah
01:25:192 (7) - same reason with 00:42:835 (7) nah
01:31:957 (1,2,3) - maybe not to stack these? no.

[hard]
00:42:246 (6) - add a note between 6 and 7 so http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/97160 and add clap to the end of 6 and on 7? it sounds better disrupts the flow, so i disagree
01:24:603 (2) - add clap to the 2nd and 3rd reverse to line up with ^ nah

[easy]
greenline at 00:00:625 - N:C1 ?_? turn it off and you'll see why it's there


nice thanks

Saten-san wrote:

woaasdsd, Reborn~♪

General:
3 sec lead-in seems too long D:. use 2 sec instead (you already storyboarded the epilepsy warning so it should be okay~) i think it's fine

on last note, increase the volume? i think it's fine

Easy
01:19:309 (3) - 1 grid up (lv.4) okay

Hard:
01:22:839 (1) - remove the whistle on the first repeat? Hard is now Normal+, and has been remapped a little

Insane:
01:22:839 (1) - End of the slider, remove whistle? nah
01:23:427 (4) - remove the whistle slide? ^
00:54:600 (3) - 1 grid up (lv.4) okay
00:55:189 (3) - 1 grid down (lv.4) okay
01:02:248 (5) - 1 grid right (lv.4) okay

(ﾉﾟωﾟ)ﾉ ~~☆☆

James2250 wrote:

-Most maps seem to have the source as "Katekyo Hitman Reborn!" but both are used so I guess up to you i've decided that for hiragana/katakana/kanji characters in anime titles, i use lowercase. if it's roman letters in capitals, then i put as capitals

Easy:
-Pretty high stats for an Easy, I recommend at least -1 for OD/AR done

Hard:
00:00:625 (1,1,1) - I wouldn't do this (especially for a Hard) deleted middle (1) and extended the first spinner

Insane:
00:00:625 (1,1,1) - still don't like it but ok :<

Some nice looking maps, just those minor things to go over and I will rank