1. Dunskin's Taiko Oni (4,89 stars, 925 notes)
2. Ende der Strasse (3,17 stars, 232 notes)
3. Haus am See (4,93 stars, 477 notes)
4. Orangenbaumblaetter (1,4 stars, 154 notes)
5. p3n's faule Huette (4,88 stars, 506 notes)

p3n wrote:

[General]
MP3 is 256kbps - don't change until a MAT/BAT demands it


[Orangenbaumblaetter]
01:25:608 (1) - someone WILL tell you this is unrankable because some ppl with strange slider graphics wont see the way the slider goes...try to leave some space in the middle or do something else entirely distanz erhöht
03:22:019 (1,1,2,1) - Would sound better with:
- 03:22:019 (1) - shorten to 03:24:929 (end on white tick); ok
- 03:25:657 (1) - move to 03:25:414 and add 1x repeat; nope
- 03:28:082 (1) - move to 03:27:840 (white tick) ^
http://puu.sh/cuKG

smooth 1,3 stars


[p3n's faule huette]
DAT MAP!!!1
update:
[attachment=0:cfcf7]Peter Fox - Haus am See (Magicphoenix) [p3n's faule Huette].osu[/attachment:cfcf7]


[Haus am See]
01:48:890 (8) - start the new combo here? [lol NC modpost lol] ok
02:33:515 (5) - move turning point [ending point] of the slider to 288/264 to make it match the orientation of 02:33:030 (4) nö
03:23:232 (6,1,2) - personally I would only use 03:23:959 - 03:24:080 - 03:24:444 - 03:24:929 - 03:25:172 as beats for the actual vocal follow here (in whatever hitobjects you want): http://puu.sh/cuPP nope


have this

Hika wrote:

hi mod request weee

SPOILER

Overall -
AAAAAA I LOVE THIS SONG <3 =)
Don't forget to change the bitrate of the mp3. okay

Orangenbaumblaetter -
00:35:649 (3) - New combo. ok
01:59:561 (1) - Remove new combo. ^
02:07:807 (1) - ^ nope
03:04:557 (2) - Finish on the tail of the slider. no
03:22:019 (1) - This slider sounds bad. Consider remapping. did

p3n's faule Huette -
The hitsounding after the 2nd kiai timing, is it finished? .. I can't tell. If it isn't finish it..
00:19:642 (5) - Remove clap.
00:21:461 (6) - ^
00:22:431 (4) - ^
00:21:825 (1) - Remove new combo.
00:22:068 (2) - New combo.
00:47:290 (3) - ^
01:45:010 (5) - ^
01:48:890 (9) - Remove clap.
02:00:774 (4) - New combo.
02:35:455 (2) - Add whistle.
03:03:102 (1) - Remove new combo.
03:09:408 (1) - ^
03:18:381 (6) - New combo.
03:25:657 (9) - ^

Haus am See -
00:19:642 (1) - Remove new combo.
00:19:885 (2) - Add new combo. ok
01:17:363 (1) - Remove new combo. ok
02:11:930 (8) - New combo.
02:12:173 (1) - Remove new combo. ok
02:15:083 (8) - New combo.
02:15:568 (1) - Remove new combo.
02:15:810 (2) - New combo. did some new combos but not like you did it, thanks for reminding
03:10:863 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - I hope this is rankable since Freestyler does it... I mean this is slower but still, GOODLUCK \:D/ it's way slower and the circle spacing is even increasing so i think it should be no problem

Sorry, I love to look at combos. x:

Good luck. <3

Hika wrote:

p3n's faule Huette -
The hitsounding after the 2nd kiai timing, is it finished? .. I can't tell. If it isn't finish it.. woah I think it got mixed up between the different versions (one on my netbook and one on the PC) changed to the final version
00:19:642 (5) - Remove clap.
00:21:461 (6) - ^
00:22:431 (4) - ^
00:21:825 (1) - Remove new combo.
00:22:068 (2) - New combo.
00:47:290 (3) - ^
01:45:010 (5) - ^
01:48:890 (9) - Remove clap.
02:00:774 (4) - New combo.
02:35:455 (2) - Add whistle.
03:03:102 (1) - Remove new combo.
03:09:408 (1) - ^
03:18:381 (6) - New combo. did something else
03:25:657 (9) - ^
everything else applied

Wiinter wrote:

[Haus am See]
00:35:649 (4) - add new combo? ok
00:52:140 (4) - i'm not sure about this, but consider using Ctrl+R to keep the jumpy pattern of the combo ok
02:18:963 (3) - add new combo here? (as added in 02:03:806 (1)) removed previous combo instead
02:19:327 (5) - same as above, but in relation to 02:04:169 (1) no change
02:58:737 (3) - add new combo? the rhythm kinda changes here nope
03:10:863 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - alskdjlaskdj why I like it, problem?

sorry for making you wait i fell asleep earlier hehehe ^^ no problem

Starry wrote:

request from queue. This is also my first German song I modded so

[General]

I think you should put a countdown to get people ready because the song starts as soon as you click the map. No it doesn't , I have cooldown lol

[Orangenbaumblaetter]

01:06:692 (2,3) - I think you should remove 3 and reverse 2. nope
01:55:681 (3,4,5) - I think a slider fits here better. ^
02:31:574 (1,2) - Remove 2 reverse 1? hmm i see what you did there, but no
03:16:198 (3) - I don't think reverse is needed. removed

[Haus am See]

00:02:181 (5) - New combo nope
00:09:457 (5) - ^ ^
00:35:649 (4) - ^ ok
02:15:083 (4) - ^ no
02:24:784 (5) - ^ ok
03:07:953 (4) - ^ nope
01:17:848 (1) - Remove new combo? no
03:16:926 (5,6,7) - Slider go better here? no change
03:20:564 (6,7) - Remove 7 reverse 6? nope

Good luck~ That's all I could find.

Starry wrote:

[p3n's faule Huette]
00:09:941 (1) - remove new combo rearranged some combos
00:13:822 (1) - ^
00:10:669 (2) - New combo
00:14:549 (2) - ^
00:42:439 (11) - ^
01:26:578 (3) - ^
01:48:890 (9) - ^
02:44:064 (5) - ^
00:40:742 (8) - This note is suppose to be like this? it is. if this is unreadable for some ppl I will change it. It sure is damn hard to play hidden
03:06:498 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Split this. if by splitting you meant combo then ok
03:10:378 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - I feel that this combo can be shorten. changed
03:28:446 (2,3) - Remove 3 reverse 2? hmm sounds better so why not

Wiinter wrote:

Hey, modding as requested

[p3n's faule Huette]
finish the 3rd kiai at the same time it does on the other diffs? (here it ends at 02:58:737, on the others at 03:06:498) fixed
consider increasing a bit the overall difficulty, it's too low for the diff's level OD+1 should be enough...this is supposed to be "hard" not "insane"
01:34:824 (6) - new combo here suits better than at 01:35:309 (1), so consider changing it done, seems reasonable
02:02:714 (6,7,8,9) - place it at the same place of 02:00:532 (1)? looks better imo it is stacked properly in play mode...the difference in the editor is just to avoid the stacking bug orz
03:03:830 (1) - remove new combo? seems unecessary to me sure

haha5957 wrote:

[p3n's]
00:07:031 - (timing section) remove it, since not needed
00:08:001 - (timing section) remove it, since not needed true...not used anymore
00:59:416 (7,9) - offscreen, not a good idea not exactly "off screen" but moved a bit closer to prevent them from touching the health bar
01:48:648 (8) - NC hmmkay
02:00:532 (1,2,3,4,5) - used grid snap and grid level 3 or 4 and redo this work - doesnt look nice here moved sliders a bit but the following stack is placed properly to prevent stacking bug during play-mode

haha5957 wrote:

[General]
Taiko's Audio lead in is 3, and others is 2... just have it have 2

[Orangenwhateverlol]

02:21:388 (2,3) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/217358 this? ok
02:49:521 (2) - just change the red point to normal point (right-click the red point) ok
I know why you did this but I don't think it looks good.. curve should cover next (1) nicely
or try this : http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/217362 if you really want symetrical shape (next : x0.88 doesnt really matter)
03:00:677 (2) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/217364 this? no

[Haus am see]
this map's circle are too cornered? I mean... like 02:28:664 (3,4,5,6) - 02:34:485 (1,2,3,4,1) -
Idk if it really matters but just pointing out.. I mean.. It feels uncomfortable for me O.O Hmm, not for me :p

00:43:409 (3,4,5) - umm, not good Why not? looks fine to me =)
01:31:671 (7,2,3) - 7,2,3 forms a strange shape... maybe move 3 a bit? Nope

• Bitrate is 256kbps. Convert this to 128~192kbps
  Why do 2 diffs have same slider velocity o.O

• Circle Size +1?

• 01:04:266 (7) - Add New Combo
  01:08:511 (2) - This note touches HP Bar
  01:12:027 (6) - Add New Combo
  02:34:485 (1) - Remove New Combo

• 00:02:181 (5) - nazi, this slider is touching (3), maybe move it upwards a few grids?
  00:30:313 (1,2,3,4) - I think using a jump here suits more than using a jump for 00:29:586 (1,2,3) -
  00:43:409 (3,4) - This doesn't look pretty to me, maybe use the symetrical shape of (4) for (3)?
  01:32:156 (1) - This note goes outside the screen
  01:38:947 (6,7) - The repeat sign is kind of difficult to read
  02:15:568 (1) - Remove New Combo
  02:15:810 (2) - Add New Combo
  03:17:411 (7) - This note feels out of place to me, maybe delete this note?

Takos wrote:

Hi~ >w</
All Suggestions

Overall

• Bitrate is 256kbps. Convert this to 128~192kbps k = =..
  Why do 2 diffs have same slider velocity o.O is it a problem?

Orangenbaumblatter

• Circle Size +1?

Haus am See

• 00:02:181 (5) - nazi, this slider is touching (3), maybe move it upwards a few grids? ok
  00:30:313 (1,2,3,4) - I think using a jump here suits more than using a jump for 00:29:586 (1,2,3) - nop
  00:43:409 (3,4) - This doesn't look pretty to me, maybe use the symetrical shape of (4) for (3)? hm i like it this way
  01:32:156 (1) - This note goes outside the screen lol xD fuixed
  01:38:947 (6,7) - The repeat sign is kind of difficult to read i don't think it is...i will change it if another modded points it out
  02:15:568 (1) - Remove New Combo
  02:15:810 (2) - Add New Combo NC follows vocal so no sorry ><
  03:17:411 (7) - This note feels out of place to me, maybe delete this note? it follows the last syllable

Good luck~

Takos wrote:

p3n's faule Huette

• 01:04:266 (7) - Add New Combo
  01:08:511 (2) - This note touches HP Bar moved a bit
  01:12:027 (6) - Add New Combo
  02:34:485 (1) - Remove New Combo
  rearranged some combos after your suggestions

• - Custom clap is cute XD
  - 03:27:840 - Didn't BPM changed at this point :\?
  - Can't mod taiko -w-

• - rofl XD

• - Hitsound's usage was a good impression, but needs improve

• - Sorry for a wrong diff name^ XD