1. Easy (2,03 stars, 176 notes)
2. Hard (4,82 stars, 471 notes)
3. Normal (3,65 stars, 244 notes)
4. Vass' Hard (4,62 stars, 395 notes)

1750044 wrote:

Easy is a bit short!

I can play only normal and I liked it. Can't comment on timings much, I'm not experienced enough but I noticed one thing about your combos. At the beginning you start new combos at hi-hat. That goes well until 00:42:372 (5) when there's still old combo at hi-hat. And next combo right after start's at 00:46:618 (1) and it's hi-hat again. Another hi-hat is at 00:49:924 (6) and it's end of combo again.

Choruses are good, second verse (starts at 01:28) is mixed (but I think the hi-hats are mixed too). Then it's all good until 03:35:755 (6) and 03:39:763 (6). Not saying those are mistakes to correct, just a feeling that it could be more smooth/consistent. It's up to your judgement on that case.

TicClick wrote:

I start new combos on every second downbeat and I don't follow finishes

Luk3 wrote:

[Vass' Hard]
00:33:392 (5) - This Slider seems a bit weird. — It became so short due to timing change. Diff is not finished yet, it's just a placeholder

[Hard]
02:20:875 (1) - Would be nice a Kiai Mode on this guitar solo. — I think it doesn't need kiai, unfortunately

1. [b]I Highly Recommend You to Find some pro timing modder to check your time points again because generally, if no bpm change, we needn't to add extra red lines. Especially the first part...I suppose you offset is off.

1. 00:46:152 - add a note here?
2. 01:03:312 (1) - do not place slider across timing point..it will cause unsnapped slider end error. Won't mention it again but pay attention, if you wanna fix that u should fix note code in osu file directly which is not allowed
3. 01:41:795 - add a note?
4. 01:56:071 (1,1,1) - i'm not very sure why u choose these NC styles, but i suppose it's not a good style. Try to make your NC more reasonable and consistent but not randomly.
5. 02:26:095 - add a note here?
6. 03:33:865 - ^?

1. 03:09:017 (3) - remove clap and finish on 03:09:482 (4) - ? and then add a finish to 03:09:947 -
2. 03:35:755 (6) - remove finish? heard weird a bit

1. 01:39:186 (1) - invisible reverse arrow
2. 02:28:929 (5) - remove whistle?

1. 00:34:812 (4) - Ctrl+r for better flow?
2. 00:39:495 (2) - ^
3. 01:11:221 (2) - ^
4. 02:19:650 - you may miss a note here :<
5. 02:59:650 (2) - i suppose it's better to start from prev redline, and no change in end
6. 03:03:367 (2) - ^

Scorpiour wrote:

Hi there~~mod from #modreq

[General]

1. I Highly Recommend You to Find some pro timing modder to check your time points again because generally, if no bpm change, we needn't to add extra red lines. Especially the first part...I suppose you offset is off. — It isn't; the song itself has incosistent timing, that's why I did so.

[Easy]

1. 00:46:152 - add a note here? — Done!
2. 01:03:312 (1) - do not place slider across timing point..it will cause unsnapped slider end error. Won't mention it again but pay attention, if you wanna fix that u should fix note code in osu file directly which is not allowed — Well, it's said in Ranking Criteria that I'm not allowed to "... manually edit anything in an .osu file that cannot be changed through the Editor". Slider's length can be changed through editor, so there's nothing wrong with it to fix slider in notepad; at least those are my thoughts and I hope I think in right direction
3. 01:41:795 - add a note? — Hmm, added
4. 01:56:071 (1,1,1) - i'm not very sure why u choose these NC styles, but i suppose it's not a good style. Try to make your NC more reasonable and consistent but not randomly. It's not random; white combo colour is for kiai fountains (uprising vocal parts), then it's followed by previous combo colour, and then I add NC to mark new part in music. As you may see, there's nothing chaotic or inconsistent
5. 02:26:095 - add a note here? — Yea, you're right
6. 03:33:865 - ^? — Yeah

[Normal]

1. 03:09:017 (3) - remove clap and finish on 03:09:482 (4) - ? and then add a finish to 03:09:947 - — Sounds bad for me, sorry. New finish isn't in music, so it doesn't fit
2. 03:35:755 (6) - remove finish? heard weird a bit — It's better to boost hitsound from music here, that's what I think

[Har]

1. 00:34:812 (4) - Ctrl+r for better flow? — Yeah!
2. 00:39:495 (2) - ^ — You're right
3. 01:11:221 (2) - ^ — Done, now it plays better
4. 02:19:650 - you may miss a note here :< — Good, good
5. 02:59:650 (2) - i suppose it's better to start from prev redline, and no change in end — Well, I tried to follow previous patterns, but your suggestion is better. Also, I remade them all
6. 03:03:367 (2) - ^ — Added a note between sliders

ouranhshc wrote:

Hard
01:40:615 (4) - soft finish on repeat? — Added

Overall for Hard
I don't understand the purpose white combo color stuff and the kiai that goes along with those white combo colors. Also with the kiai, why does this section 03:11:572~03:21:127 kiai but 01:52:321~02:01:923. Also, you have TOO MANY KIAI FOUNTAINS. If you really want to emphasize the parts where he raises the pitch of his voice, do it through spacing. — Ok, I will remove fountains but leave white colour

Normal
00:29:605 (3,4) - i don't recommend doing this for a normal — Not stacked anymore
01:31:362 (6,1) - ^ — ^
02:19:901 (1) - remove new combo — It follows music
02:22:555 (4,5) - i don't recommend doing this for a normal — Yeah, removed that stack
02:26:095 (3,4) - ^ — ^
02:43:591 (7) - remove new combo — Ok

Overall for Normal
Same combo and kiai issues as Hard

Easy
Changed some combos
02:20:875 (1) - Too close to (5) — 0.8x now

Overall for Easy
Same combo and kiai issues as hard

Raging Bull wrote:

Normal:
03:02:430 (1) - Perhaps make this spinner end 1/1 earlier? Might not be enough time for beginners to recover after a spin — Done!

Insane:
02:22:555 (1) - Not a big problem but perhaps making the map tick rate 2 would make slowdowns easier to read? Especially if someone doesn't know the song and wants to SS a song, it could be an easier guide to see that the slider is slower. Or do something similar like vass did. — Eh, but other diffs use tick rate 1! Also, it's only 0.7x at such small amount of BPM, so it won't cause anything bad

Quilt wrote:

Normal

SPOILER

02:18:242 (3) - delete note? — Don't want to delete it, because it follows music

02:34:372 (4) - ^ — Same as above

02:42:864 (6) - ^ — Same as above

03:02:430 (1) - spinerend 03:05:260 - Done!

03:06:212 (1) - and move a little covered with 300 — It's in center so people know how to catch it

03:40:493 (1) - remove NC — Nooo, I need it

Hard

SPOILER

01:15:751 (4) - umm overlap — Changed

• 00:36:231 (2,3,4) - Ну не в тему же.
  01:29:930 (3) - Продлить слайдер немного вперед(?)
  01:33:750 (3) - ^
  02:16:563 - Может быть, добавить сюда что-нибудь?

• 
  01:31:123 - Добавить ноту? (или это "не баг, а фича"?)