aabc271 wrote:

As requested by taiko_maniac, I'm coming for a Taiko mod ~
Let's go :3

Blue~ Critical issues. You must fix this
Purple~ It's better to fix this
Pink~ Suggestions / thoughts only. Change only if you want to

-----------------------

[Taiko Oni]

00:00:954 ~ 00:10:063 - The 1/1 d x16 are followed by intense streams, which means the diff spread is very big. You should use some more complex patterns at the first 16-notes part, and maybe dividing the streams into sections. You may consider the following :

• 00:00:954 ( 1~16 ) - Change to "d d dkd d d dkdkd" x2 ? ( The last d in will be the 1st note of stream )
  00:07:001 ( 1,2,3 ) - Delete them ( To shorten the stream and reduce diff spread )
  00:08:257 ( 2,1 ) - ^
  00:09:357 ( 6 ) - ^

^ i don't think it really is necessary too shorten the streams ._. i mean, i'm following the drum beats of the song on that particular part...
but i will consider too shorten it but not now...

01:05:666 ( 1,2,1,1,1 ) - I personally think notes -> Instant spinner are odd, esp when the notes are in even number ( I dislike the spinner icon being covered partially like this ). Try removing the last d, or start spinner at 01:06:137 and add d at 01:05:980 ?

^ b-but it fits the song ;w; keeping the spinner for now

Suggested patterns

Suggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~

01:18:859 ( 1 ) - Add finish ? ( You can hear that the beat is slightly heavier than the previous ones. So adding finish here will be nice ) ok desu~

As the style of music allows large proportion of custom patterns, I'll say the hitsounds & patterns are basically fine ~

-----------------------

[Taiko Muzukashii]

00:08:493 ( 1 ) - End this spinner at 00:10:063. You can hear significant drum hit at that point, so doing this will fit the music much better. oops, putted it a bit too long >_> fixed

01:05:666 ( 14~17, 1 ) - Same as Oni. Try removing 17 ? no ;w;

Suggested patterns

Suggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~

00:02:838 ( 6, 12 ) - Both Blue notes ? ( To avoid repeats of d d d ) i want consistent repetition here...

00:07:864 ( 21, 22 ) - ^ ( To fit the vocal better and avoid having all red notes ) ^

01:18:859 ( 1 ) - Add finish ? ( Same reason as Oni ) ok desu~

Nice use of hitsounds & custom patterns. Good job :3

-----------------------

[Taiko Futsuu]

00:08:493 ( 1 ) - End this spinner at 00:10:063. ( Same as Muzu ) ok desu~
01:05:980 ( 1 ) - Similar to above, the music stops at 01:07:393, and so it should end there ~ ^

Suggested patterns

Suggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~

00:07:864 ( 10 ) - Blue note ? ( imo this fits the vocal better ) me still want consistent repetiton =3=

01:18:859 ( 5 ) - Add finish ? ( Same as Oni ) ok desu~

Also nice diff. I guess players can hit the beats in correct timing ?

-----------------------

[Taiko Kantan]

I'm not sure if newbies can understand the timing of beats correctly, as this kantan is a lot more complex than ordinary ones ( in terms of beats ). You'd better find some testplayers and see how they perform ~

^ don't worry, i've tested it with some of my friends that doesn't have any experience playing rhythm games (well some of them) and they say it's nice :3

00:08:493 ( 1 ) - End this at 00:10:063. ( Still same as Muzu )
01:05:980 ( 1 ) - End this at 01:07:393. ( Same as Futsuu )

^ done desu~

Suggested patterns

Suggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~

00:07:864 ( 8 ) - Blue note ? ( Fits the vocal better, same as Futsuu ) me still want consistent repetition =3=

01:18:859 ( 1 ) - Add finish ? ( Same as Oni ) ok desu~

Well, this is also fine, but the beats could be quite complex ~

-----------------------

Generally all diffs are fine, as you can see I suggest the same things over and over again www

Star and good luck ~

Stefan wrote:

Let's see.

[Kantan]
HP +1, I don't think that Beginner are THAT bad, and this is too easy to pass for beginner. ok ._.
00:02:210 (2,4) - k ok
00:12:891 (1) - k, I don't really think that the d sounds good or does really follow the pattern before. ^
00:17:917 (1) - ^ ^
00:24:828 (4) - I would avoid this Circle to set it here. Since the Rhythm at 00:23:571 (1,2,3) - mix 1/1 with 1/2, this Circle can be hard to hit for Beginner. I suggest to move it at 00:25:142. It won't lacks on rhythm feeling imo. i've deleted the note to make things easier lol
00:29:854 (3) - k ok
00:54:828 (1,2,3) - imo it won't be wrong if you move them to the next white Ticks. Because you may should follow more the BG Music instead the Voice.
Otherwise, delete at least 00:55:142 (2). deleted note at 00:55:142
01:13:205 (3,4) - Change them to d. Sounds fine too and make it easier to play. done
01:18:231 (3,4) - ^ ^

[Futsuu]
00:02:838 - I don't get why you don't add a k here. ok ._.
00:04:723 (1) - d ^
00:05:351 - circle with k ^
00:05:666 - ^ I think k at 00:05:351 should be enough so no ._.
00:07:864 (4) - k me like it to be d =3= so no
00:14:933 (5,6,7) - Maybe this? http://puu.sh/1jupm ok but I only moved (6,7)
00:28:597 (1) - Move it to 00:28:440, since it fits better with the Music. but it still plays fine if I don't move it, yes :3
00:31:739 (3) - k ok
00:43:048 (1) - d, but it's up to you. nah k sounds nice :3
00:43:362 (2) - remove it why ;A;" it sounds nice ;_; so no ._.
00:44:304 (2) - k ok
00:44:933 (1) - d ^
00:47:289 (3) - Move it to 00:47:446. ok
00:47:760 (4) - delete it (this and the Suggestion above should be taken by you, since the transistion is bad here at (3) ). done
00:48:545 (5) - K ok
00:53:100 (1) - k d sounds fine to me ._.
00:57:341 (3) - Move it to 00:57:498. ok
00:57:812 (4) - delete it (Same reason as 00:47:760) done
00:58:597 (5) - K ok
01:03:152 (1) - k d sounds fine to me ._.
01:13:362 (3) - delete it, it's not really neccessary for the Futsuu.. v
01:18:388 (3) - ^ but you may keep it for a good Finish of the Diff let me keep it :3

[Muzukashii]
The thing I immediately noticed is that the Diff has many many circles and in all respect, you really should delete some stuff. Mostly, when I suggest to delete the Circle, it's because it's too much and you probably should follow it. Feel free to ignore this advice, it's just my opinion.
HP -1 done
00:02:838 (6) - k ok
00:05:351 (12) - k ^
00:07:707 (20,22,24) - I consider to remove them. ^
00:13:048 (2) - imo you could delete it for a better rhythm feeling done
00:13:990 (2) - ^ ^
00:15:325 (7) - The Triplet is bad and could be easily removed. I thought so too ._. deleted
00:15:404 (1) - k (if you follow the suggestion above) ok
00:18:074 (2) - remove it, same reason as 00:13:048. ^
00:18:545 (1) - k ^
00:19:802 (5,6) - remove them ^
00:20:116 (6) - move it to 00:20:273 for a better flow. ^
00:21:058 (2,3,4) - Also here, the triplet is not really neccessary and it sounds a bit too much. Remove the Circle at the blue Tick. ok
00:21:844 (5,6,7) - ^ ^
00:23:100 (1) - remove it ^
00:23:257 (2) - k ^
00:24:828 (2,3) - k ^
00:23:414 (3) - remove it ok
00:23:807 (2) - ^ ^
00:24:043 (1) - d k fits the sound of the piano so no ._.
00:24:435 (2) - remove it ok
00:24:514 (2) - k (just if you follow the suggestion above) ok
00:25:299 (2) - remove it for now no ._.
00:25:613 (1,2) - d no
00:25:927 (1) - D ok
00:27:184 (1) - k no ._.
00:29:854 (1) - D ok
00:30:168 (1) - ^ ^
00:30:561 (2) - remove it ^
00:30:796 (1) - d (if you follow the suggestion above) k sounds fine to me so no ._.
00:31:111 (1) - D ok
00:31:425 (1) - d ^
00:31:896 (1) - delete it ^
00:51:215 (1) - D d here sounds fine to me
00:55:535 (3) - move it to 00:55:299 since I feel that it sounds good here. me want triplets here :3
01:01:739 (2,3,4) - d ok
01:01:817 (3) - remove it i think triplets here plays nice so no change for now
01:03:781 (2) - D ^
01:03:859 (3) - remove it ^
01:05:744 (15,16) - remove it, the transistion from the circle to Spinner is good if you delete them. ^
01:15:953 (3) - remove it ok
01:17:446 (1) - ^ to avoid a long combo for now no change ._.

[Oni]
01:04:723 (145) - K I think D fits nicely :3

[Inner Oni]
00:02:838 (7) - k ok
00:03:152 (8) - Move it to 00:02:995 and make it to k. It sounds good. done, yeah sounds nice :3
00:05:351 (15,16) - Same as the Suggestions before.^
00:09:749 (11,12) - k me like d more =w=
00:25:927 (1,2,3) - IMO you should delete (2,3) and add Finish on (1) ok
00:49:880 (2) - This sounds for me too much here. I suggest to delete it. nah it's fine :3
00:59:933 (2) - Same here.no change ._.

Well, this is all I could find. MMzz did a great job as always. orz